MURDER IN THE MARGINS

A LUCY BLACKSTONE MYSTERY

BOOK 5

MAISY MARPLE

with

WENDY WINCHESTER

JOIN THE MYSTERY CLUB

Love Cozy Mysteries? Get Full Series on Release Day!

No more waiting for the next book—binge the *entire* series the moment it launches! Bestselling mystery author **Maisy Marple** has teamed up with six talented authors to bring you **better books, faster!**

books 7 Authors, Full Series on Day One – No waiting for the next book!

wrapped gift Free Books & Exclusive Discounts – Just for subscribers!

fire All Books in Kindle Unlimited – Read for free with your membership!

If you love cozy mysteries, this is the newsletter you *can’t* miss! CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP! woman detectivesparkles

MURDER IN THE MARGINS

History has secrets worth killing for...

When beloved local historian Clara Beth Jennings is found dead at the Brentwood Falls Annual Book Fair, town librarian Lucy Blackstone is devastated. Clara Beth's mysterious final words—"The footnotes hold the truth"—seem like the meaningless ramblings of a dying woman. But Lucy knows better.

As she digs into Clara Beth's historical research, Lucy discovers something shocking: someone has been systematically altering Brentwood Falls' historical records. What started as missing library books and altered footnotes leads to a trail of deception stretching back over a century—to a suspicious death and a land dispute that made one family's fortune while destroying another's future.

With the powerful Barlow family trying to suppress Clara Beth's discoveries and the mayor insisting some things are "best left buried," Lucy finds herself in a race against time. The killer is still at large, and Lucy's persistent questions have made her their next target.

Armed with her librarian's eye for detail and her unwavering commitment to the truth, Lucy must decode Clara Beth's cryptic message before the killer rewrites history again—with Lucy's demise as the final chapter.

1

Lucy Blackstone believed in the power of the perfect bookmark. Tissue-thin receipts, candy wrappers, and dog-eared corners were literary sacrilege in her professional opinion. Which was why she was currently arranging a display of handcrafted leather bookmarks at the entrance to the Annual Brentwood Falls Book Fair with the dedication of someone decorating a wedding altar.

"Just a smidge to the left," she instructed Marge, her assistant librarian, who was hanging a banner above their table. "We want it perfectly centered when people walk in."

Marge, a no-nonsense woman in her sixties who had been working at the Brentwood Falls Library since card catalogs were cutting-edge technology, sighed dramatically. "Lucy, honey, it's a banner for a small-town book fair, not the Declaration of Independence. Nobody's going to notice if it's half an inch off."

"I'll notice," Lucy replied cheerfully, adjusting one final bookmark. "And so will Mrs. Fincher, who will absolutely point it out to everyone who enters."

The late September morning was crisp and clear, perfect weather for the outdoor event. White tents dotted the library grounds like literary mushrooms, each housing local authors, book collectors, artisans selling reading-adjacent crafts, and the crown jewel of this year's fair: the rare books exhibit.

Lucy checked her watch. "Almost opening time. I should go check on Clara Beth. She was still fussing with her display when I walked by earlier."

"That woman would reorganize the Library of Congress given half a chance," Marge muttered, but with obvious affection.

Lucy made her way through the maze of booths, greeting volunteers and vendors as she passed. The fair had grown considerably since she'd first proposed it six years ago, shortly after becoming head librarian. What had started as a modest used book sale had blossomed into Brentwood Falls' premier literary event, drawing visitors from neighboring towns and even a few dedicated bibliophiles from the city.

She spotted Clara Beth Jennings at the far corner of the grounds, beneath a stately oak tree. Even from a distance, Lucy could see the local historian arranging and rearranging items on her table with laser focus. At seventy-eight, Clara Beth had the energy of someone half her age and twice the determination.

"Everything coming together, Clara Beth?" Lucy called as she approached.

Clara Beth looked up, her silver-rimmed glasses perched precariously on the end of her nose. "Lucy, dear! Just in time. Come see what I've discovered!" Her voice carried the excited tremor of someone clutching a winning lottery ticket.

The table before her held several leather-bound volumes, carefully arranged on velvet cloths. Protective glass cases housed what appeared to be maps and documents yellowed with age. A hand-lettered sign proclaimed: "Hidden Histories of Brentwood Falls: Secrets in Plain Sight."

Clara Beth gestured Lucy closer with a conspiratorial wave. "I've been going through old town records—probate inventories, council minutes, personal correspondence—and I've found something remarkable." She lowered her voice. "Something that will change how we understand the founding of Brentwood Falls."

"That sounds fascinating," Lucy said, genuinely interested. As town librarian, local history fell squarely within her wheelhouse of passions. "What kind of discovery?"

Clara Beth glanced around, then carefully lifted a particularly weathered volume. "This is Jeremiah Wells' personal journal from 1879. He was the town's first mayor, you know."

"I remember you mentioning it when you donated a copy of his biography to the library," Lucy nodded.

"Well, this isn't a copy. This is the original," Clara Beth said, her eyes gleaming. "Found it in an estate sale over in Millfield. The family had no idea what they had." She carefully opened the journal to a marked page. "Look here, in the margins. See these tiny notations?"

Lucy leaned closer, squinting at the faded handwriting. Alongside the main text were indeed tiny notes, almost invisible unless you were looking for them.

"Footnotes," Clara Beth explained triumphantly. "And in them, Jeremiah reveals that the official story of how Brentwood Falls was founded is a fabrication."

Before Lucy could ask for details, a shadow fell across the table. They looked up to see Mayor Levi Parson standing there, his campaign-ready smile notably absent.

"Clara Beth," he said, his voice carrying a forced pleasantness. "I thought we discussed this yesterday."

Clara Beth straightened to her full five-foot-two height. "We did. And I told you then what I'm telling you now: historical truth isn't something you can suppress because it's inconvenient."

The mayor's smile tightened. "No one's talking about suppression. I'm simply suggesting that unverified claims about town founders might be better discussed after proper academic review." He glanced at Lucy. "Rather than splashed across a public event."

"Unverified?" Clara Beth's voice rose an octave. "I have primary sources, Levi. Documents that your great-grandfather's memoirs conveniently omitted."

Lucy's eyebrows shot up. This was clearly a conversation with history—recent and ancient—that she wasn't privy to.

Mayor Parson placed both hands on the table, leaning forward slightly. "Clara Beth, as mayor of Brentwood Falls and a direct descendant of one of its founding families, I'm asking you—respectfully—to reconsider this display. You're digging up things best left buried."

"History isn't meant to stay buried, Levi," Clara Beth replied firmly. "And if your family had been more forthcoming a hundred years ago, I wouldn't need to excavate it now."

The mayor straightened, adjusting his tie. "I see you've made up your mind." He nodded curtly to Lucy. "Ms. Blackstone. I hope the rest of the fair is less... controversial." With that, he turned and strode away, his shoulders rigid beneath his tailored jacket.

"Well!" Lucy exhaled. "That was tense. What exactly have you discovered that has the mayor so concerned?"

Clara Beth's eyes sparkled with a mixture of academic excitement and mischief. "The truth, my dear. And the truth is always uncomfortable for those who've built their reputations on convenient fictions." She patted the journal lovingly. "It's all here in the footnotes. Jeremiah Wells had a habit of keeping dual records—the official version in the main text and the unvarnished truth in his marginalia."

She looked up at Lucy, suddenly serious. "Stop by later this afternoon. Around three. I'll have everything organized by then, and I'd like to show you something specific." She glanced in the direction the mayor had gone. "Something that might explain our dear mayor's discomfort."

"I'll be there," Lucy promised, curiosity thoroughly piqued. "But I should get back to the entrance. We open in ten minutes."

As Lucy walked away, she glanced back to see Clara Beth once again absorbed in her documents, hunched over them with the protective posture of someone guarding treasure.

The morning flew by in a whirlwind of activity. Lucy found herself constantly in motion—welcoming visitors, directing lost attendees to specific booths, solving minor crises (Mrs. Fincher's complaint about the romance novels being too prominently displayed, a coffee spill threatening a collection of signed first editions), and occasionally sneaking moments to browse the offerings herself.

By early afternoon, the fair was in full swing. The grounds buzzed with the particular energy only book lovers could generate—that hushed excitement of discoveries being made, stories being shared, and the gentle rustle of pages being turned.

Lucy had just finished helping a young mother find age-appropriate mystery novels for her reluctant reader son when Hazel Carter, her best friend and owner of The Daily Grind café, appeared with two steaming cups.

"You look like you need this more than oxygen," Hazel said, handing Lucy a large coffee. "I've been watching you practically teleport around the grounds for the last three hours."

Lucy accepted the cup gratefully. "My kingdom for caffeine. How's the café booth doing?"

"Selling bookish-themed treats faster than we can restock," Hazel grinned. "The literary cupcakes are a hit—turns out people love eating Moby Dick's face."

Lucy laughed, taking a restorative sip of coffee. "Have you had a chance to wander around? Clara Beth Jennings has the most fascinating display of local historical materials."

"Not yet, but it's on my list," Hazel replied. "Speaking of Clara Beth, did you see her showdown with Mayor Parson this morning? Half the town's talking about it."

"I was there for the tail end," Lucy admitted. "Something about historical records and family histories. The mayor seemed... displeased."

"Displeased is putting it mildly," Hazel snorted. "Marge said he stormed over to the refreshment tent afterward and stress-ate three maple scones while complaining to anyone who would listen about 'irresponsible historical speculation.'"

Lucy frowned. "That's odd. The mayor's usually so careful about his public image."

"Must be something pretty significant to ruffle his feathers," Hazel agreed. "Clara Beth mentioned something to me last week about a major discovery, but she was being very mysterious about it. Said it would 'rewrite local history.'"

Before Lucy could respond, Tom Wentworth, one of Brentwood Falls' deputy sheriffs, approached with his customary measured stride. With his pressed uniform and serious expression, he looked somewhat out of place amid the festive atmosphere.

"Afternoon, ladies," he greeted them. "Great turnout this year, Lucy."

"Thanks, Tom. Enjoying the fair?"

"On duty, unfortunately," he replied with a small smile. "Sheriff asked me to maintain a presence, especially around the rare book exhibition. Some pretty valuable items on display."

"Always the responsible one," Hazel teased. "Even when surrounded by the wild danger of... books."

Tom's smile widened slightly. "You'd be surprised. Last year at the Millfield Antiquarian Book Show, someone tried to walk out with a first edition Hemingway tucked under their jacket."

"The horror," Hazel gasped in mock distress.

Lucy checked her watch. "Speaking of the exhibition, I promised Clara Beth I'd stop by her booth around three. She wanted to show me something specific about her discovery."

"Better you than the mayor," Hazel remarked. "I thought he was going to combust on the spot."

As they chatted, Lucy noticed the crowd's movement patterns shifting. A small commotion seemed to be occurring near the rare books section. She saw several people moving toward Clara Beth's corner of the grounds, some walking quickly, others with the hesitant steps of those unsure if they should approach at all.

"Something's happening," she murmured, setting down her coffee cup. A prickle of unease traveled up her spine.

Tom had noticed it too. His casual posture immediately transformed into alert readiness. "Stay here," he instructed, already moving toward the disturbance.

Lucy and Hazel exchanged glances.

"You know we're not staying here, right?" Hazel said.

"Obviously," Lucy replied, and they both followed in Tom's wake.

As they drew closer to Clara Beth's booth, the murmurs from the gathering crowd grew more distinct. Lucy caught fragments—"just collapsed," "doesn't look right," "someone call an ambulance."

Her pace quickened. Pushing past the last few onlookers, Lucy froze at what she saw.

Clara Beth Jennings was slumped forward across her display table, her silver head resting on the open journal she'd been so excited about that morning. One hand was outstretched, as if reaching for something. Her glasses had fallen onto the table, one lens cracked.

Tom was already beside her, fingers pressed to her neck, checking for a pulse. His expression told Lucy everything before he even spoke.

"Everyone please step back," he commanded, his voice carrying the unmistakable authority of his position. "This is now an official investigation scene."

Lucy stepped forward anyway. "Tom, it's Clara Beth. Is she...?"

His eyes met hers, grim confirmation in their depths. "I'm sorry, Lucy. She's gone."

A wave of murmurs rippled through the onlookers. Someone sobbed quietly.

Lucy approached the table, her librarian's eye automatically cataloging details. Clara Beth's display had been disturbed—books and documents were askew, not at all in the meticulous arrangement she'd maintained that morning. And there was a conspicuous empty space on the velvet cloth, a slightly darker rectangle where something had clearly been removed.

"Tom," she said quietly, pointing. "Something's missing."

The deputy followed her gaze and nodded fractionally, already pulling out his phone. "Sheriff Pritchard? We have a situation at the library grounds. Elderly female, deceased. Circumstances are... unclear. Yes, sir. Right away."

As Tom continued his report, Lucy noticed something else. Clara Beth's notebook—the one she always carried to record her research findings—lay open beside her, a pen still clutched in her limp fingers. On the visible page was a single sentence, the handwriting shaky and incomplete: "The footnotes hold the truth."

Lucy stared at those words, a chill settling over her that had nothing to do with the September breeze. She glanced at Clara Beth's still form, then back at the notebook, unable to shake the feeling that the local historian's final message had been meant specifically for her.

In the distance, sirens wailed, growing louder as they approached the library grounds. The Annual Book Fair, which had begun with such promise and excitement, had taken a dark and unexpected turn. And somehow, Lucy suspected that the cryptic reference to footnotes would prove to be far more significant than anyone yet realized.

2

The wail of sirens shattered the previously cheerful atmosphere of the Brentwood Falls Book Fair. Parents shepherded curious children away from Clara Beth's booth while Deputy Tom Wentworth established a hasty perimeter using book fair signage and yellow caution tape from his patrol car.

Lucy stood rooted to the spot, her mind struggling to process what her eyes were seeing. Clara Beth Jennings—town historian, notorious early riser, and possessor of the sharpest memory in three counties—was gone. The woman who could recall the exact date the town's first stoplight was installed couldn't possibly be dead at her own booth, surrounded by the historical artifacts she'd cherished.

"Lucy." Hazel's gentle voice broke through her stupor. "Maybe we should step back and let Tom do his job."

Before Lucy could respond, Sheriff Hank Pritchard strode through the gathering crowd, his weathered face set in the professional mask he reserved for serious situations. Unlike his deputy's crisp uniform, the sheriff wore what Lucy thought of as his working clothes—khaki pants, a buttoned shirt with rolled-up sleeves, and a worn leather jacket despite the mild September weather.

"Tom," he acknowledged with a nod. "Secure the scene. Nobody touches anything." His gaze fell on Lucy and Hazel. "Ladies, I need you to step back now."

"Hank, it's Clara Beth," Lucy said, unable to keep the tremor from her voice. "Who would do this?"

The sheriff's expression softened slightly. "That's what I'm here to find out. But I can't do that with civilians in my crime scene."

"Crime scene?" Hazel echoed. "You don't think she just... had a heart attack or something?"

Hank exchanged a glance with Tom, then stepped closer to them, lowering his voice. "Between us, no. There are signs of foul play. Now please, step back."

As they reluctantly retreated beyond the makeshift perimeter, Lucy watched Hank kneel beside Clara Beth's body. His movements were methodical as he examined her without disturbing the scene, his eyes narrowing as he gently tilted her head to examine her neck.

"What's he looking at?" Hazel whispered.

"I think..." Lucy trailed off, squinting. From their new position, she could see what hadn't been visible before—a thin, angry red line across Clara Beth's throat, partially hidden by her collar. "Oh no."

Sheriff Pritchard straightened and beckoned Tom closer, speaking in hushed tones. The deputy's face grew grim as he nodded and immediately began scanning the ground around the booth.

Dr. Miriam Langley, the county medical examiner, arrived moments later. A petite woman with steel-gray hair pulled back in a severe bun, she approached the scene with brisk efficiency, exchanging brief words with Hank before turning her full attention to Clara Beth.

Hazel squeezed Lucy's arm. "We should give them space to work."

"I can't just walk away," Lucy protested. "Clara Beth was going to show me something important. She said—" She broke off, the historian's last written words flashing in her mind: The footnotes hold the truth.

"Said what?" Hazel prompted.

"That she'd discovered something in the footnotes of Jeremiah Wells' journal. Something that would 'change how we understand the founding of Brentwood Falls.'" Lucy's gaze drifted back to the booth. "And now the journal is missing."

"Missing?" Hazel followed her gaze. "Are you sure?"

"Positive. It was on the table this morning—leather-bound, about this big," Lucy indicated with her hands. "Clara Beth was showing it to me right before the mayor came over."

"Speaking of the mayor..." Hazel nodded discreetly toward the edge of the crowd.

Mayor Levi Parson stood several yards away, his face ashen as he watched the proceedings. When Dr. Langley carefully lifted Clara Beth's head to examine her neck more thoroughly, the mayor seemed to flinch, then abruptly turned and walked away, moving with the hurried steps of someone trying not to run.

"That was odd," Lucy murmured.

"Well, he did argue with her this morning," Hazel pointed out. "Seeing her dead a few hours later would rattle anyone."

Before Lucy could respond, Sheriff Pritchard approached them, his expression grave.

"Lucy, I understand you spoke with the victim earlier today?"

"Yes, around opening time. She was excited about her display, especially an old journal she'd acquired. Jeremiah Wells' personal journal from 1879."

"And this journal—was it valuable?"

"Historically, extremely," Lucy confirmed. "Monetarily... I'm not sure. But it would certainly appeal to collectors of local historical artifacts."

Hank's mouth tightened. "It appears to be missing from the scene. In fact, Dr. Langley's preliminary assessment suggests Clara Beth was murdered—strangled with a thin cord or wire—likely during a busy period when the crowd would mask the attack."

Lucy felt her stomach lurch. "Murdered? You're certain?"

"The ligature marks are unmistakable," Hank confirmed grimly. "She was killed right here at her booth, probably by someone who approached as if interested in her display."

"For the journal?" Hazel asked, horrified.

"Possibly," Hank replied. "Robbery is our leading theory at the moment."

Lucy shook her head. "It doesn't make sense. Why not just steal it when no one was looking? Why kill her?"

"Maybe she caught them in the act," Hank suggested. "Or maybe the killer knew she could identify them." He pulled out a small notebook. "Did Clara Beth mention anyone being particularly interested in the journal? Any unusual visitors to her booth?"

"No, but—" Lucy hesitated, then decided complete honesty was necessary. "She had a rather tense conversation with Mayor Parson this morning. He seemed upset about her display."

The sheriff's expression revealed nothing. "I'll speak with the mayor. Anyone else?"

"Not that I saw," Lucy admitted. "But I wasn't with her all day."

"Alright. I'd appreciate it if you both stuck around. We'll need formal statements once the scene is processed." Hank glanced back at the booth. "And Lucy? I know how your mind works. Leave the investigating to the professionals this time."

As the sheriff returned to the crime scene, Hazel gave Lucy a knowing look. "He's right, you know. This isn't a missing library book—it's murder."

"I know," Lucy said quietly. "But Clara Beth was going to show me something important. She specifically asked me to come back at three." She checked her watch: 2:47 PM. "Whatever she discovered was significant enough that someone killed her to keep it quiet."

"Or they just wanted the valuable journal," Hazel countered reasonably.

"Maybe," Lucy conceded, though she didn't sound convinced. She scanned the area surrounding Clara Beth's booth, her librarian's eye for detail automatically cataloging the scene.

Something white fluttered beneath a nearby table, nearly hidden in the grass. While Hazel spoke with another concerned fair attendee, Lucy casually drifted closer, pretending to adjust her shoe. When she was certain no one was watching, she quickly bent down and retrieved what appeared to be a torn piece of paper.

It was a fragment of notebook paper, covered in Clara Beth's distinctive handwriting. Most of it was illegible—just partial words and phrases—but one line stood out clearly: "Wells confession contradicts Parson family claims about—"The rest was torn away.

Lucy quickly pocketed the fragment, her heart racing. Whatever Clara Beth had discovered in Jeremiah Wells' journal apparently contradicted something about the Parson family—the mayor's family, one of the town's oldest and most respected lineages.

As she straightened, she noticed a familiar figure hovering at the edge of the crowd—Tilly Harper, the energetic thirty-something reporter for the Brentwood Falls Gazette. With her ever-present messenger bag and an expression that vacillated between professional concern and journalistic excitement, Tilly was taking notes and occasionally snapping photos with her phone.

Seeing Lucy looking her way, Tilly immediately approached, lowering her voice to a respectful murmur. "Lucy, this is awful. I spoke with Clara Beth just this morning."

"You did? About what?"

"Her historical discovery," Tilly replied. "She was being cryptic, but promised me an exclusive once she'd 'assembled all the evidence.' Said it would be the biggest story I'd ever cover in Brentwood Falls."

"Did she mention a journal? Jeremiah Wells' personal journal?"

Tilly's eyes widened slightly. "Yes, actually. That's why I recognized the name when you mentioned it. I checked out his published memoirs from the library last week after Clara Beth suggested I read up on him."

That caught Lucy's attention. "Clara Beth specifically directed you to research Jeremiah Wells?"

"She said it would provide 'necessary background' for her revelation." Tilly hesitated. "Do they know yet what happened to her?"

"Sheriff Pritchard believes she was murdered," Lucy said quietly, watching Tilly's reaction.

The reporter blanched. "Murdered? In broad daylight? At the book fair?" Each question rose in pitch. "That's... that's not supposed to happen in Brentwood Falls."

"No, it's not," Lucy agreed grimly. "Did Clara Beth mention anything specific about her discovery? Anything about the Parson family, perhaps?"

Tilly looked thoughtful. "Not explicitly. But she did say something about how 'certain prominent families wouldn't be pleased' by what she'd found." She glanced toward where Mayor Parson had been standing earlier. "You don't think...?"

"I don't know what to think yet," Lucy said honestly. "But Clara Beth's historical journal is missing, and her last written words were about footnotes holding the truth."

"Classic Clara Beth," Tilly said with sad fondness. "Always said the real story was in the details everyone else overlooked." She pulled out a business card. "If you learn anything more, call me? Off the record, of course."

Lucy accepted the card noncommittally. "I should get back. Sheriff Pritchard wants statements from everyone who spoke with Clara Beth today."

As Tilly moved away to interview other witnesses, Lucy noticed a stocky woman in an expensive tweed jacket examining some of the other rare book displays. Josie Fairbanks, the region's most notorious book collector, whose private library was rumored to rival some university collections.

Lucy approached her, putting on a professional smile. "Ms. Fairbanks, I didn't realize you were attending our fair today."

Josie turned, adjusting her designer glasses. "Miss Blackstone. Yes, Clara Beth invited me specifically. Said she had acquired something I might find fascinating." Her British accent, which Lucy suspected was affected rather than authentic, seemed particularly pronounced today.

"Jeremiah Wells' journal?" Lucy suggested.

"Indeed. Though I confess I was more interested in its historical significance than its collectible value." Josie's expression softened slightly. "Poor Clara Beth. Such a vibrant mind, right until the end."

"Did you speak with her today?"

"Briefly, this morning. She was quite animated about her discovery."

"Did she mention what exactly she'd found in the journal?"

Josie hesitated. "She alluded to something about the town's founding families—said she was 'rewriting portions of the town history.' I assumed she was being typically dramatic." She adjusted her jacket. "I understand the journal is now missing?"

"Yes," Lucy confirmed, watching Josie's reaction closely. "Along with whatever secrets it contained."

"How unfortunate." Josie's tone was carefully neutral. "Historical documents of that nature belong in proper archives, not in private collections."

"Like yours?" Lucy couldn't resist asking.

Josie's smile didn't reach her eyes. "My collection is meticulously preserved, cataloged, and made available to serious scholars. But I take your point." She glanced at her watch. "If you'll excuse me, I should take my leave. I expect the fair will be closing soon, given the circumstances."

As Josie walked away, Lucy felt her suspicions deepening. The book collector had seemed unusually reserved, especially for someone known for her passionate pursuit of rare volumes.

Lucy made her way back to where Hazel was waiting near the refreshment tent, now largely abandoned as word of Clara Beth's death spread throughout the fair.

"Well?" Hazel asked. "Learn anything interesting from your not-at-all-obvious sleuthing?"

Lucy pulled her aside, keeping her voice low. "Clara Beth was researching something about the town's founding families—specifically something that contradicts the Parson family history."

"Based on...?"

Lucy showed her the torn fragment of notes. "This, plus conversations with Tilly Harper and Josie Fairbanks. Clara Beth told Tilly her discovery would be 'the biggest story she'd ever cover' and told Josie she was 'rewriting portions of town history.'"

"Rewriting history is figurative, Lucy," Hazel pointed out. "It doesn't mean someone would kill her over it."

"Unless the history in question threatens someone's present-day reputation or position," Lucy countered. "The mayor was adamant that she should stop her research—said she was 'digging up things best left buried.'"

"You can't seriously think Mayor Parson strangled an elderly historian in public over some ancient town gossip."

Lucy sighed. "I don't know what to think. But I do know that Clara Beth was killed right before she was going to show me something important, and the primary evidence is now missing."

"Which suggests robbery," Hazel insisted.

"Or a cover-up disguised as robbery," Lucy replied, her mind racing with possibilities. "Think about it—Clara Beth discovers something significant in Jeremiah Wells' journal footnotes, something that contradicts established history about the Parson family. She plans to make it public at the book fair. The mayor confronts her, trying to dissuade her. When that fails..."

Hazel looked skeptical. "That's a pretty big leap, Lucy. Besides, the mayor isn't the only one with motive. Tilly might have wanted an exclusive scoop. Josie might have wanted the rare journal for her collection. Heck, any serious book thief would know a murder would bring more attention, not less."

"You're right," Lucy admitted. "I'm getting ahead of myself. But one thing is certain—Clara Beth's death wasn't a simple robbery gone wrong. She discovered something someone wanted to keep hidden." She looked back toward the booth, where Clara Beth's body was now being carefully placed on a stretcher. "And her last message was meant for me."

Sheriff Pritchard approached them, looking tired. "We're wrapping up here. The fair is officially closed for the day."

"Hank, what happens now?" Lucy asked.

"Now we investigate a homicide," he replied grimly. "We'll need to search Clara Beth's home, interview everyone who spoke with her today, and try to locate the missing journal."

"And if the journal was stolen to hide whatever Clara Beth discovered?" Lucy pressed.

Hank gave her a knowing look. "Then we'll still find the truth. That's my job, Lucy." His expression softened slightly. "I know you cared about Clara Beth. So did a lot of people in this town. But trust me to handle this investigation."

Lucy nodded reluctantly. "Of course."

As the sheriff walked away, Hazel linked her arm through Lucy's. "Come on. Let's get you home. It's been a terrible day."

"I can't just go home and pretend this didn't happen," Lucy protested.

"I'm not suggesting that," Hazel replied reasonably. "I'm suggesting you take the evening to process, and then approach this clearly tomorrow. Clara Beth would want you to be methodical, not impulsive."

Lucy had to smile at that. "You're right. Clara Beth despised sloppy research."

As they walked toward the parking lot, Lucy couldn't shake the feeling that she was missing something obvious. The historian's final message kept repeating in her mind: The footnotes hold the truth.

But which footnotes? And what truth was worth killing for?

3

Despite Hazel's sensible suggestion to take the evening to process, Lucy found herself returning to the library after dropping her friend off at The Daily Grind. The book fair tents still stood on the grounds, looking forlorn and abandoned behind the police tape that now surrounded the area. Lucy used her back entrance key, slipping into the quiet building as the sun began to set.

The library after hours had always been one of her favorite places—the unique stillness of a space designed for concentration, the comforting smell of books and wood polish, the gentle ticking of the old grandfather clock in the reference section. Tonight, however, it felt different. Shadows seemed deeper, silence more oppressive, as if the building itself mourned Clara Beth's passing.

Lucy moved purposefully through the stacks toward her office. If Clara Beth had been researching Jeremiah Wells and the town's founding, there had to be a paper trail. The historian was nothing if not methodical, often spending weeks working through the library's resources before reaching any conclusions.

At her desk, Lucy pulled up the library's catalog system. A quick search for Jeremiah Wells returned several results—his published memoirs, two biographies written decades after his death, and various town records from his time as mayor. Lucy narrowed her eyes, thinking back to her conversation with Tilly Harper. The reporter had mentioned checking out Wells' published memoirs on Clara Beth's recommendation.

A few more clicks brought up the circulation history. Lucy rarely accessed this information—patron privacy was sacrosanct in library ethics—but these were extraordinary circumstances. Sure enough, Tilly Harper had checked out "Reflections of Brentwood Falls: The Collected Writings of Jeremiah Wells" two weeks ago and returned it just three days prior.

"That can't be a coincidence," Lucy murmured to the empty room.

She next searched for the specific title Clara Beth had mentioned that morning—Jeremiah Wells' personal journal from 1879. No results appeared in the catalog.

"Of course not," Lucy muttered. "Clara Beth said she'd just acquired it at an estate sale."

But Clara Beth must have been cross-referencing the journal with other local history sources. Lucy searched the catalog for any books on Brentwood Falls history checked out in the past month. The results showed one particular volume that caught her eye: "Foundation and Growth: A Historical Account of Brentwood Falls 1870-1900."

According to the system, it had been checked out three times recently—first by Clara Beth six weeks ago, then by Tilly Harper two weeks ago, and finally by Clara Beth again just last week. It was currently marked as "returned" and should be on the shelves.

Lucy headed to the Local History section, running her finger along the spines until she reached where "Foundation and Growth" should be. The space was empty.

"That's odd," she frowned. If the book was marked as returned in the system but wasn't on the shelf, it could be misshelved, in use in the reading room, or...

A third, more troubling possibility occurred to her. Could someone have removed it deliberately?

Lucy methodically searched the surrounding shelves, then expanded her search to nearby carts and reading tables. No sign of the missing volume. She checked the sorting shelf behind the circulation desk where recently returned books awaited reshelving. Nothing.

With growing frustration, Lucy returned to her office and picked up the phone. It was well past business hours, but this couldn't wait.

Tilly answered on the third ring, her voice wary. "Lucy? Is everything okay?"

"I need to ask you about 'Foundation and Growth: A Historical Account of Brentwood Falls.' You checked it out recently."

There was a brief pause. "Yes, on Clara Beth's recommendation. She said it would provide context for her discovery."

"Did she tell you what to look for specifically?"

"The footnotes," Tilly replied immediately. "She said, 'always check the footnotes when official history seems too tidy.' I didn't understand what she meant until I started reading them."

Lucy's pulse quickened. "What was in them?"

"That's just it—they were strange. Some seemed to reference documents I couldn't find. Others hinted at conflicts that weren't explained in the main text." Tilly's voice dropped slightly. "And a couple appeared to have been... tampered with."

"Tampered with?"

"Altered. Or maybe partially erased and rewritten? The handwriting and ink were different in spots."

Lucy frowned. "This was a library book. Defacing it would be⁠—"

"I know, I know," Tilly interrupted. "I almost reported it, but then I realized it might be important to whatever Clara Beth was investigating. I made photocopies of the suspicious pages before returning it."

"I need to see those copies," Lucy said urgently.

"I was planning to ask Clara Beth about them at the book fair," Tilly said, her voice softening. "Now I guess we'll never know what she discovered."

"We might," Lucy countered. "If I can find that book."

"It should be at the library. I returned it last Friday—put it in the drop box myself."

"It's not on the shelves," Lucy explained. "And after what happened to Clara Beth, I don't think that's a coincidence."

There was a long pause on the line. "You think someone took it because of what Clara Beth found?"

"It's possible," Lucy admitted. "Can I see your photocopies? Tonight?"

Twenty minutes later, Lucy sat in her office examining the photocopied pages Tilly had brought. The reporter hovered nearby, fidgeting with her press badge.

"I don't know if these will help," Tilly said. "They're just the pages that looked odd to me."

Lucy spread the copies across her desk. They showed several pages from "Foundation and Growth," with footnotes circled in red marker. Tilly was right—some of the footnotes did appear unusual. In a few cases, the handwriting style changed mid-note, as if someone had erased the original text and added their own.

One footnote in particular caught Lucy's attention. It referenced a land dispute from 1882 involving several founding families:

"The northwestern boundary claims were eventually resolved through arbitration, with the Parson, Wells, and Fairchild properties established as originally deeded. The Barlow claim [different handwriting begins] was dismissed due to insufficient documentation [original handwriting resumes] though some controversy remained."

"See how the middle part looks different?" Tilly pointed out. "The ink is darker and the handwriting more cramped."

Lucy nodded slowly. "Someone altered the historical record. But why focus on the Barlow family's land claim?"

"The Barlows?" Tilly's eyebrows shot up. "As in Frank Barlow, the bank president?"

"His ancestors, yes. They were one of the original settler families, though not as prominent as the Parsons or the Wellses." Lucy tapped the altered footnote thoughtfully. "This might be what Clara Beth discovered—evidence that the historical records had been deliberately changed."

"But who would care about a land dispute from the 1880s?" Tilly asked, perplexed.

"Someone whose current reputation or position might be affected by the truth," Lucy replied. "Clara Beth said her discovery would change how we understand the founding of Brentwood Falls."

Lucy continued examining the photocopies, noting each discrepancy. Another footnote mentioned "conflicting accounts" of how Jeremiah Wells acquired his initial property holdings, with a reference to "personal journal entries" that contradicted the official record.

"This must be why Clara Beth was so excited about finding Wells' personal journal," Lucy murmured. "It contained his uncensored account of these events."

"So someone altered the official history books to hide... what? A shady land deal from 140 years ago?" Tilly sounded skeptical.

"Maybe it was more than that," Lucy said slowly. "Clara Beth told me that Jeremiah Wells kept 'dual records'—the official version in the main text of his writings and 'the unvarnished truth' in his marginalia and footnotes."

Lucy's mind was racing. "I need to see the original book, not just these copies. And I need to know what Clara Beth found in Wells' personal journal that got her killed."

"You really think that's why she was murdered? Over historical footnotes?"

"People have killed for less," Lucy replied grimly. "Especially when reputation and legacy are at stake."

With Tilly's help, Lucy conducted a more thorough search of the library, checking every conceivable place where "Foundation and Growth" might have been misshelved or hidden. Their efforts proved fruitless.

"It's not here," Lucy finally admitted, leaning against a shelf in defeat. "Someone must have taken it after you returned it."

"Who would have access?" Tilly asked.

"Anyone who visited the library in the past week," Lucy sighed. "It's a public building."

"What about after hours?"

Lucy considered this. "Only staff have keys. That's me, Marge, and our part-time page, Jeremy Collins. Plus the cleaning service and the maintenance supervisor."

"And the board members?" Tilly suggested.

Lucy blinked. "Yes, technically the library board members have access codes for board meetings. That includes Mayor Parson, Frank Barlow, and a few others."

Tilly's eyes widened. "The mayor and Frank Barlow both have after-hours access? The same people mentioned in those altered footnotes about land disputes?"

"It's circumstantial," Lucy cautioned, though her own suspicions were growing. "We can't accuse people based on library access alone."

"But it's a starting point," Tilly insisted. "Especially combined with the mayor's confrontation with Clara Beth and now these altered footnotes about the Barlow family."

Lucy glanced at her watch—nearly 10 PM. "It's too late to do anything more tonight. But first thing tomorrow, I'm going to talk to Frank Barlow. If his family is mentioned in these altered footnotes, he might know something about why someone would want to hide this history."

"And the mayor?" Tilly prompted.

"One thing at a time," Lucy replied. "If I start directly questioning the mayor about murder, Sheriff Pritchard will have my library card."

After Tilly left, Lucy made copies of the photocopies—evidence of evidence—and locked them in her office safe. The original photocopies she secured in her messenger bag to take home. She couldn't shake the feeling that Clara Beth's discovery was significant enough that someone might go to extreme lengths to suppress it.

The next morning, Lucy arrived at First Brentwood Bank just as it opened. Franklin "Frank" Barlow had been president of the town's only bank for nearly fifteen years, following in his father's and grandfather's footsteps. His family's connections to the town ran as deep as the Parsons', though with less public prominence.

Frank looked up in surprise when Lucy was shown into his office. "Lucy! What brings you to the bank so early? Nothing wrong with the library accounts, I hope?"

"No, nothing like that," Lucy assured him, taking the offered seat across from his imposing mahogany desk. "I'm actually here about something historical."

Frank's expression was pleasantly neutral, though Lucy thought she detected a flicker of wariness in his eyes. "Historical? That's an unusual topic for a banking discussion."

"It's about Clara Beth Jennings' research," Lucy said, watching him carefully. "She was investigating some inconsistencies in the town's historical records before she died."

"Ah." Frank leaned back slightly. "A terrible tragedy. Have they determined what happened?"

"Sheriff Pritchard believes she was murdered," Lucy said bluntly.

Frank's eyebrows rose. "Murdered? At the book fair? That's... difficult to believe."

"Nevertheless, it's true. And a valuable historical journal she was displaying is now missing."

"I see." Frank adjusted his gold cufflinks—a nervous habit Lucy had noticed during library board meetings. "But I'm not sure how this concerns the bank, or me personally."

"Clara Beth discovered alterations to historical footnotes in a book about Brentwood Falls' founding," Lucy explained, deciding directness was her best approach. "Specifically, footnotes regarding a land dispute involving your family in the 1880s."

Frank went very still. "My family?"

Lucy nodded. "The original text apparently referenced some controversy about the Barlow land claim being dismissed. The footnote appears to have been altered at some point to change the historical record."

"That's... interesting," Frank said carefully. "But hardly relevant today. Ancient land disputes are just that—ancient history."

"Unless they reveal something about how certain families acquired their status in Brentwood Falls," Lucy suggested.

Frank's smile tightened almost imperceptibly. "The Barlows have been respected members of this community for generations, Lucy. We have nothing to hide about our history."

But Lucy noticed his right hand trembled slightly as he adjusted his tie. "The book that contained these footnotes—'Foundation and Growth: A Historical Account of Brentwood Falls'—has gone missing from the library. It was returned last week but is no longer on the shelves."

"Books go missing from libraries all the time," Frank replied smoothly. "People misshelve them, forget to return them, take them without checking them out."

"This one disappeared after Clara Beth began her research, and now she's dead," Lucy countered. "It seems like an unlikely coincidence."

Frank's expression hardened. "Are you implying something, Lucy?"

"I'm just trying to understand what Clara Beth discovered that might have led to her murder. As a library board member, I thought you might want to help preserve the historical record."

"Of course," Frank said, his professional demeanor firmly back in place. "But I don't see how speculation about altered footnotes in an old book connects to Clara Beth's tragic death. And I certainly don't appreciate the insinuation that my family has anything to hide."

Lucy decided to take a different tack. "You're probably right. But as a historian, Clara Beth valued accuracy above all else. If she found evidence that historical records had been tampered with, she would have wanted to correct them. That's all I'm trying to do—honor her work by finding the truth."

Frank seemed to relax slightly. "A commendable goal. But I'm afraid I can't help you with missing library books or historical footnotes about land disputes from before my grandfather's time."

As Lucy stood to leave, she had one more question. "Do you know if your family kept any records from that era? Deeds, letters, journals? Anything that might shed light on the original land claims?"

Something flickered in Frank's eyes—recognition? Concern? "Not that I'm aware of. Most of those documents would have been transferred to the county records office long ago."

He was lying. Lucy's years of watching patrons search for "lost" library cards had honed her ability to detect dishonesty. Frank Barlow knew something about those historical records.

"Well, if you happen to come across anything, I'd appreciate you letting me know," Lucy said pleasantly. "Clara Beth would have wanted the historical record to be accurate."

As she left the bank, Lucy's mind was working overtime. Both Mayor Parson and Frank Barlow had reacted defensively to questions about the town's history. Both had access to the library after hours. And both had family names mentioned in the disputed historical footnotes.

But would either of them kill to protect a historical secret? It seemed extreme, yet Clara Beth was dead, the journal was missing, and "Foundation and Growth" had vanished from the library shelves.

Lucy's next stop was Clara Beth's home. Sheriff Pritchard would have already searched it for evidence, but Lucy wasn't looking for murder weapons or fingerprints. She was looking for research notes—the kind of historical breadcrumbs that only another bookish person would recognize as significant.

Clara Beth lived—had lived, Lucy corrected herself with a pang—in a small Victorian cottage on Maple Street, its exterior painted a cheerful yellow with white trim. Deputy Tom Wentworth was just leaving as Lucy arrived.

"Lucy," he greeted her with resigned recognition. "I should have known you'd turn up."

"Just paying my respects," Lucy said, attempting innocence.

Tom's expression made it clear he wasn't fooled. "Sheriff Pritchard mentioned you might come by. He said to tell you that we've already collected all relevant evidence, and that civilians should not interfere with an active investigation."

"Of course," Lucy nodded solemnly.

Tom sighed. "But he also said that if you happened to notice anything of historical significance that might not seem important to us, you should let him know immediately."

Lucy brightened. "So I can go in?"

"We've finished processing the scene," Tom conceded. "Just... don't touch anything you don't have to, okay? And call the sheriff if you find anything relevant to the case."

As Tom drove away, Lucy approached the cottage with mixed emotions. She'd visited Clara Beth many times over the years for tea and historical discussions. Entering her home now, knowing she would never again hear the historian's animated theories about local artifacts, felt like trespassing.

Inside, the cottage was exactly as Lucy remembered it—walls lined with bookshelves, display cases of historical memorabilia, a desk by the window perpetually covered in research materials. The sheriff's search had been thorough but respectful; things were out of place but not disarrayed.

Lucy moved to Clara Beth's study, the heart of her historical work. Here, the search had been more intensive. Drawers stood open, papers had been sorted through, books examined and replaced. Lucy wasn't sure what she was looking for until she spotted it—Clara Beth's research journal, a leather-bound notebook where she documented all her investigations.

Sheriff Pritchard had obviously examined it, but had left it behind as not immediately relevant to the murder investigation. Lucy carefully opened it, finding Clara Beth's meticulous notes about her recent discoveries.

The most recent entries detailed her excitement about acquiring Jeremiah Wells' personal journal and her growing suspicions about discrepancies in the town's official history. One passage in particular caught Lucy's attention:

"The footnotes in 'Foundation and Growth' have been deliberately altered—comparing them with Wells' personal accounts confirms my suspicions. Someone systematically changed the historical record about the original land grants. The question is: why? And do the descendants of those involved know the truth about their family legacies?"

Clara Beth had then listed several names—Parson, Barlow, Fairchild—with question marks beside them. Under the Barlow name, she'd written: "Current position built on historical fiction?"

Lucy frowned at this cryptic note. What did Clara Beth mean by "current position"? Frank Barlow's role as bank president? The family's standing in the community?

The final entry in the journal, dated just two days before the book fair, was even more intriguing:

"Wells' journal contains the proof I need. The footnotes were right all along—you just needed to know how to read them. The founding families will need to confront an uncomfortable truth about their precious legacy. Some may never forgive me, but history demands accuracy."

Lucy closed the journal thoughtfully. Clara Beth had definitely discovered something significant in those footnotes—something worth killing for, if her suspicions were correct. But what exactly was the "uncomfortable truth" about Brentwood Falls' founding families?

And more importantly, where was Jeremiah Wells' personal journal that contained the proof?

Lucy carefully replaced Clara Beth's research journal exactly as she'd found it. Her librarian's instinct told her the answer lay in those elusive footnotes—both in the missing book and the missing journal. She just needed to figure out how to read them the way Clara Beth had.

As she left the cottage, Lucy's determination hardened. Clara Beth had dedicated her life to preserving accurate history. The least Lucy could do was ensure that her final discovery wasn't buried along with her.

4

Lucy Blackstone had always believed that town halls should be welcoming places, but as she climbed the steps to Brentwood Falls' municipal building, she felt distinctly unwelcome. The imposing brick structure, with its white columns and copper dome, seemed to be watching her approach with disapproval.

"You're being ridiculous," she muttered to herself. "Buildings don't judge."

She'd called ahead to request a meeting with Mayor Levi Parson, citing "urgent library business" as her reason. His secretary had reluctantly squeezed her in between the mayor's budget meeting and his lunch with the Chamber of Commerce.

The lobby was quiet, with just a few citizens waiting for various administrative services. Lucy nodded to Phyllis Gordon, who'd manned the front desk since Lucy was in elementary school.

"He's expecting you," Phyllis said, her tone suggesting she found this surprising. "Third door on the right."

Lucy made her way down the carpeted hallway, pausing briefly before the mayor's door to gather her thoughts. She needed to tread carefully—direct accusations would only make him defensive.

She knocked lightly.

"Come in," called the mayor's distinctive baritone.

Mayor Levi Parson sat behind a desk that seemed designed to impress and intimidate. Family photographs lined the credenza behind him—generations of Parsons who had shaped Brentwood Falls. The current Parson, a handsome man in his early fifties with salt-and-pepper hair and a politician's smile, rose to greet her.

"Lucy! What can I do for our esteemed librarian today? Something about the fall budget allocation?"

His tone was friendly, but Lucy noticed it didn't match his eyes, which remained watchful and wary.

"Thank you for seeing me, Mayor," Lucy replied, taking the offered seat. "Actually, I'm here about Clara Beth Jennings."

The mayor's smile dimmed several watts. "Ah. A terrible tragedy. The whole town is in shock."

"Especially those who spoke with her shortly before her death," Lucy observed. "Like you."

Mayor Parson's expression shifted—a subtle tightening around the mouth, a slight narrowing of the eyes. "Yes, I did have a brief conversation with her at the book fair. Sheriff Pritchard has already taken my statement about that."

"I was there for part of your conversation," Lucy reminded him. "You seemed upset about something she was planning to display."

The mayor leaned back in his chair, steepling his fingers. "Clara Beth was... passionate about local history. Sometimes overly so, particularly when it came to historical controversies that have little relevance to modern Brentwood Falls."

"What kind of controversies?"

"Old disputes, ancient grudges, the usual small-town politics of a century ago." He waved dismissively. "Hardly matters now, does it?"

"It might," Lucy countered, "if those old disputes somehow connect to her murder."

The mayor's head jerked up. "Murder? I thought it was a robbery gone wrong."

"Sheriff Pritchard confirmed she was strangled," Lucy said, watching his reaction carefully. "And Jeremiah Wells' journal—the one she was so excited about—is missing."

"Well, there you have it," Mayor Parson replied, recovering quickly. "A thief wanted the valuable antique book, Clara Beth caught them in the act, and tragedy ensued. Terrible, but not particularly mysterious."

Lucy decided to take a more direct approach. "Mayor Parson, what exactly did you mean when you told Clara Beth she was 'digging up things best left buried'?"

The mayor's knuckles whitened slightly as he gripped his chair's armrests. "I simply meant that some historical squabbles serve no purpose when revisited. Clara Beth had a tendency to... overstate the significance of her discoveries."

"What was she planning to reveal that concerned you so much?"

"Nothing that concerned me personally," he insisted. "I was merely trying to prevent her from potentially embarrassing certain families with unsubstantiated claims about their ancestors. As mayor, maintaining community harmony is part of my responsibility."

"Which families?" Lucy pressed.

Mayor Parson stood abruptly. "I've indulged these questions out of respect for you, Lucy, but I have another appointment in ten minutes. If there's nothing else library-related to discuss..."

Lucy remained seated. "Clara Beth's last words referenced footnotes holding the truth. The book she was researching, 'Foundation and Growth,' has also mysteriously disappeared from the library. Don't you find that suspicious?"

The mayor's professional facade cracked slightly. "What I find suspicious is your apparent determination to turn a tragic theft into some sort of historical conspiracy. Clara Beth was killed for a valuable book, not for footnotes." He moved toward the door. "Now, if you'll excuse me."

As Lucy reluctantly stood to leave, she tried one final question. "Did you know that Clara Beth met with Frank Barlow last week?"

She hadn't known this for certain, but the mayor's momentary freeze told her she'd hit on something significant.

"I don't keep track of Clara Beth's social calendar," he finally said, his voice carefully neutral. "Frank is a respected community leader and a friend. There's nothing unusual about him meeting with a local historian."

"Of course not," Lucy agreed pleasantly. "I just thought it was interesting timing—right after she found Jeremiah Wells' journal, and right before she was murdered."

The mayor's smile was now entirely gone. "I think Sheriff Pritchard would appreciate you sharing these... theories with him rather than conducting your own investigation. Good day, Lucy."

As the door closed firmly behind her, Lucy knew she'd struck a nerve. The mayor was definitely hiding something—but was it simply embarrassment over historical family secrets, or something more sinister?

Her next stop was The Daily Grind. Hazel kept her café open through the traditional mid-morning lull specifically because it had become Brentwood Falls' unofficial information exchange—the place where gossip flowed as freely as the coffee.

"So?" Hazel asked the moment Lucy slid onto a counter stool. "Did our esteemed mayor confess to strangling Clara Beth to protect the Parson family honor?"

"Not quite," Lucy replied dryly. "But he definitely knows more than he's saying. He practically pushed me out the door when I mentioned Clara Beth meeting with Frank Barlow."

Hazel raised an eyebrow as she slid a mug of herbal tea—Lucy's usual—across the counter. "Was that a real meeting, or were you fishing?"

"Fishing," Lucy admitted. "But I caught something. You should have seen his face."

"Hmm." Hazel wiped down the counter thoughtfully. "You know, now that you mention it, I did see Clara Beth and Frank having an intense conversation at table seven last Thursday."

Lucy nearly spilled her tea. "What? Why didn't you tell me?"

"Because until this moment, I didn't think it was relevant to anything," Hazel replied reasonably. "People have meetings in cafés all the time. It's literally why I have tables."

"What were they discussing? Did you hear anything?"

"I'm not in the habit of eavesdropping on my customers," Hazel said primly, then grinned. "Much. They were keeping their voices down, but Clara Beth seemed to be showing Frank something in a folder. He looked... uncomfortable."

Lucy's mind raced. "Thursday would have been right after she acquired Wells' journal. She must have found something that specifically concerned the Barlow family."

"Speaking of family concerns," Hazel nodded toward the café entrance, "your favorite customer just arrived."

Lucy turned to see Maggie Sue Robbins entering the café. The town's most beloved fourth-grade teacher had been a fixture in Brentwood Falls for over thirty years, teaching generations of local children—including Lucy herself. She was also a dedicated local history buff who had frequently collaborated with Clara Beth on educational projects.

"Maggie Sue," Lucy called, waving her over. "Join us?"

The older woman approached, her perpetually cheerful face clouded with grief. "Lucy, Hazel. What a terrible couple of days it's been."

"Absolutely awful," Hazel agreed, already pouring Maggie Sue's preferred chamomile tea. "We were just talking about Clara Beth."

"Such a loss to the community," Maggie Sue sighed, settling onto the stool beside Lucy. "The children adored her classroom visits. Who else would dress up as Abigail Adams just to make a lesson on the Revolutionary War more exciting?"

Lucy smiled at the memory. "Clara Beth certainly had a flair for bringing history to life. Were you working with her on any projects recently?"

"Not officially," Maggie Sue replied, "though she did ask me about accessing the county land records last month. Said she was researching the original property divisions of Brentwood Falls."

Lucy and Hazel exchanged meaningful glances.

"Did she say why she was interested in land records specifically?" Lucy asked.

Maggie Sue blew gently on her tea. "She mentioned something about inconsistencies in the historical narrative—said the public records didn't match some private documents she'd found. You know how she was about historical accuracy—like a dog with a bone once she found a discrepancy."

"Did she mention which families' lands she was researching?"

"The original founding families, I believe," Maggie Sue said. "The Parsons, the Wellses, the Barlows, the Fairchilds—those who established the town boundaries in the 1870s."

Lucy nodded thoughtfully. "Do you remember if she ever talked about footnotes? Specifically in 'Foundation and Growth'?"

Maggie Sue's eyes lit up with recognition. "Yes! She was quite excited about that. Said someone had altered the footnotes in the library's copy to change the historical record about a land dispute. She was trying to find the original county documents to prove it." She shook her head sadly. "Clara Beth believed that historical truth was sacred. The idea that someone would deliberately tamper with the record offended her deeply."

"Did she say who she thought had altered the footnotes?" Hazel asked.

"No, but she was determined to set the record straight." Maggie Sue leaned forward confidentially. "Between us, I got the impression she was building a case against someone—collecting evidence methodically, like she was preparing for a courtroom rather than just historical documentation."

Lucy's pulse quickened. "What kind of case?"

Maggie Sue looked thoughtful. "She mentioned something about the 'original crime' finally coming to light. I assumed she meant something metaphorical—like historical injustice—but now I wonder..."

"Wonder what?" Lucy prompted.

"If she was investigating an actual crime from the past," Maggie Sue finished. "Something beyond just misleading footnotes."

A chill ran through Lucy despite the warm café. "When did you last speak with her?"

"Last Wednesday, at the county records office. She was practically buzzing with excitement, said she'd found something that 'changed everything' and confirmed her suspicions." Maggie Sue's expression fell. "She was going to tell me all about it after the book fair."

Lucy thanked Maggie Sue for the information, promising to keep her updated on the memorial service plans for Clara Beth. As the teacher left, Lucy turned to Hazel with renewed determination.

"I need to get to the county records office. If Clara Beth found something significant there last Wednesday, it might be the key to understanding what got her killed."

"You're really not going to let this go, are you?" Hazel sighed.

"She was murdered, Hazel. Someone strangled her in broad daylight at my book fair, in my library." Lucy's voice was quiet but intense. "Of course I'm not letting it go."

The county records office was housed in a modern annex to the historic courthouse in Millfield, fifteen miles from Brentwood Falls. Lucy had called ahead to ask about their recent visitors, and the clerk had confirmed that Clara Beth Jennings had indeed spent several hours there the previous Wednesday.

"She requested a number of land deed records from the 1880s," the helpful clerk informed Lucy. "Plus some old newspaper archives from around the same time period."

"Do you keep records of which specific documents people request?" Lucy asked hopefully.

"We have a sign-out sheet," the clerk confirmed. "I can check what Ms. Jennings looked at, if that would help?"

A few minutes later, Lucy was examining a neatly printed list of the materials Clara Beth had requested during her final research session. Most were land deeds and property maps from 1880-1885, specifically focusing on the northwestern section of what was now Brentwood Falls. But one item at the bottom of the list caught Lucy's attention:

Millfield Gazette, September 15-30, 1885. Microfilm Archive Reel #17.

"Can I access this microfilm reel?" Lucy asked the clerk.

Twenty minutes later, Lucy was hunched over a microfilm reader, carefully scanning through the brittle newspaper pages from nearly 140 years ago. She wasn't sure what she was looking for, but something in these old newspapers had excited Clara Beth enough to claim she'd found "proof."

She was nearly ready to give up when a headline from September 23, 1885, leapt out at her:

MYSTERIOUS DEATH FOLLOWS LAND DISPUTE

Lucy quickly read the article, her heart racing:

James Fairchild, 62, was found dead yesterday morning at his home on the northwestern edge of Brentwood Falls. The circumstances of his passing have raised questions among neighbors, who report hearing a heated argument the previous evening. Mr. Fairchild had been engaged in an ongoing dispute with neighboring landowner Emmett Barlow regarding boundary lines, a matter scheduled for arbitration next week.

Sheriff Williams reports no signs of forced entry, though Mr. Fairchild's papers appear to have been disturbed. The county physician has ruled the death as resulting from "natural causes, likely heart failure," but this has not quelled speculation among locals that Mr. Fairchild's passing at this particular time is "mighty convenient" for certain interested parties.

Lucy sat back, her mind working rapidly. This had to be what Clara Beth discovered—a suspicious death connected to the very land dispute mentioned in the altered footnotes. If James Fairchild had died under mysterious circumstances just before a land arbitration involving the Barlow family, and then the historical record about that dispute had been altered...

She continued scanning through subsequent editions of the newspaper. Buried on page four of the September 28 issue was a small follow-up:

The property dispute between the late James Fairchild and Emmett Barlow has been resolved in favor of Mr. Barlow, as the documentation presented by the Fairchild estate was deemed "insufficient" by arbitrators. The expanded Barlow holdings now include the valuable creek access previously claimed by Fairchild.

Lucy quickly made photocopies of these articles, her mind connecting the dots. Clara Beth must have discovered evidence suggesting that James Fairchild's death wasn't from natural causes at all—that it might have been murder, conveniently timed to ensure the Barlow family won the land dispute. And that land, with its "valuable creek access," had potentially set the foundation for the Barlow family's prosperity over the coming generations.

If Clara Beth had found proof that the Barlows' position in Brentwood Falls was built on a historical murder, it would certainly explain why someone might want to silence her. But was Frank Barlow really capable of killing to protect a family secret from over a century ago?

She thought of his trembling hand during their conversation, his insistence that "ancient land disputes" were irrelevant. What if he knew exactly what his ancestor had done, and the lengths taken to cover it up?

Lucy checked her watch—nearly 3:00 PM. The library would be bustling with after-school visitors. Marge could handle things for another hour or so. Right now, Lucy needed to follow this thread while it was hot.

Where else might Clara Beth have kept notes about her discovery? She'd already checked the historian's home, and the sheriff's department had thoroughly searched her book fair booth.

Then it hit her—Clara Beth's office at the Brentwood Falls Historical Society. The small, volunteer-run organization operated out of a converted Victorian house on Elm Street. As the society's longest-serving board member, Clara Beth had a dedicated workspace there.

Twenty minutes later, Lucy was explaining her mission to Walter Phillips, the society's current president. A retired history professor with perpetually ink-stained fingers, Walter had been devastated by Clara Beth's death.

"Of course you can check her office," he agreed. "We haven't touched anything yet. None of us have had the heart to go through her things."

Clara Beth's office was exactly what Lucy expected—organized chaos, with books, folders, and artifacts arranged in a system that probably made perfect sense to its creator but appeared random to anyone else. Framed maps and historical photographs covered the walls, and a vintage metal filing cabinet stood in the corner, its drawers labeled by era.

Lucy headed straight for the drawer marked "1880-1900." Inside, she found meticulously organized folders, each labeled with a specific topic or family name. The "Barlow" folder was conspicuously missing.

"Walter," she called. "Do you know if Clara Beth removed any files recently? Specifically about the Barlow family?"

Walter appeared in the doorway, frowning thoughtfully. "She did take some materials last week. Said she needed them for her book fair presentation."

Lucy's heart sank. Those files would have been at Clara Beth's booth—and were now either with the sheriff as evidence or stolen along with Wells' journal.

She continued searching through the remaining folders, looking for anything that might connect to the land dispute or James Fairchild's death. In the "Fairchild" folder, she found copies of land deeds, family records, and a small envelope labeled "Creek Boundary - Original Survey."

Inside was a hand-drawn map dated 1878, showing property lines along a creek that now ran through what was the wealthiest part of Brentwood Falls. The map clearly showed the creek running through Fairchild property—contradicting the later records that placed it within Barlow land.

Paperclipped to the map was a note in Clara Beth's handwriting:

Original survey vs. post-1885 records. The creek boundary "mysteriously" shifted after James Fairchild's death. Wells knew the truth—check journal footnotes re: "convenient passing" and "stolen waters."

Lucy carefully photographed these documents with her phone. This had to be connected to what Clara Beth had discovered—evidence that the Barlow family had not only benefited from a suspicious death but had actively altered historical records to hide their illegitimate claim to valuable land.

As she continued searching, Lucy found one more intriguing item—a small leather-bound datebook that Clara Beth had apparently used to track her research appointments. The entry for last Thursday—the day Hazel had seen her meeting with Frank Barlow—contained one line:

1 PM - F.B. at Daily Grind. Present findings re: creek boundary + J.F. death. Opportunity to correct record before publication.

Lucy sat back in Clara Beth's chair, the implications sinking in. Clara Beth hadn't been just researching historical footnotes—she'd been investigating what she believed was a century-old murder that had been covered up and erased from the historical record. And before going public with her discoveries, she'd approached Frank Barlow—giving him a chance to "correct the record."

Had that meeting gone badly? Had Frank realized the damage Clara Beth's revelations could do to his family's reputation—and perhaps to the bank's standing, which was built on generations of respected community leadership?

Or was there someone else who couldn't risk Clara Beth's discoveries coming to light? Mayor Parson had been adamant about stopping her research. The footnotes also mentioned the Parson family's land claims being "established as originally deeded"—what if those deeds had also been questionable?

Lucy gathered her notes and photographs, thanking Walter for his help. As she left the Historical Society, she couldn't shake the feeling that she was getting closer to a dangerous truth—one that had already led to Clara Beth's murder.

The question was: had Clara Beth been killed because she discovered a historical murder from 1885, or because someone in the present day couldn't risk that history coming to light?

5

The Brentwood Falls Town Archives occupied the basement of the municipal building, a warren of climate-controlled rooms filled with the accumulated paperwork of nearly 150 years of small-town governance. Lucy had always found it both intimidating and exhilarating—a treasure trove of history where each box potentially contained untold stories.

Today, however, she approached with purpose rather than her usual archival wanderlust. If Clara Beth had discovered alterations to historical footnotes, the original town records might reveal what had been changed—and why someone would kill to keep it hidden.

Doris Whitaker, the town archivist, looked up from her desk with surprise as Lucy entered. A formidable woman in her sixties with steel-rimmed glasses and a perpetual cardigan regardless of the season, Doris guarded the archives with the vigilance of a dragon protecting its hoard.

"Lucy! Twice in one month? To what do I owe this pleasure?"

"Hello, Doris," Lucy smiled. "I'm doing some follow-up research on something Clara Beth Jennings was working on before she... before the book fair."

Doris's expression softened immediately. "Such a tragedy. Clara Beth was one of our most dedicated researchers. Always meticulous with the materials, too."

"Do you remember what she was researching recently?"

"Of course," Doris nodded, reaching for her visitor log. "She was here quite often in the past few weeks. Mostly focused on the northwestern boundary settlement of 1885—land records, arbitration documents, town council minutes from that period."

Lucy's pulse quickened. "Do you happen to know if she found what she was looking for?"

"Not entirely," Doris replied, frowning slightly. "She seemed... frustrated during her last visit. Said something about records being 'sanitized' and needing to find original sources." The archivist adjusted her glasses. "Between us, she was quite upset about some missing pages she'd hoped to find."

"Missing pages?"

"From the town council minutes of September 1885. She'd found references to those minutes in other documents but couldn't locate the actual records. Not unusual for materials that old—pages go missing, bindings deteriorate, floods happen."

"But Clara Beth thought it was deliberate?" Lucy pressed.

Doris hesitated, clearly uncomfortable. "She... had theories. Clara Beth sometimes saw patterns where others might see coincidence."

"I'd like to see the same materials she was reviewing," Lucy said. "Particularly anything related to the land dispute between the Fairchild and Barlow families."

Doris's eyebrows rose slightly, but she nodded. "Sign the log, please. I'll gather what we have."

Twenty minutes later, Lucy sat at a research table surrounded by acid-free boxes containing town records from the 1880s. She started with the land arbitration documents, carefully examining the official decisions regarding the northwestern boundary dispute.

The formal resolution, dated October 1, 1885, confirmed what Lucy had already learned from the newspaper articles: the disputed creek-side property had been awarded to Emmett Barlow after James Fairchild's death, due to "insufficient documentation" presented by the Fairchild estate.

What was interesting, however, was what wasn't there. The arbitration documents referenced "previous testimony" and "prior council deliberations" that should have been recorded in the September town council minutes—the very minutes Clara Beth had found missing.

Lucy next examined the town council record books, leather-bound volumes where meetings had been meticulously transcribed by a succession of town clerks. The August 1885 minutes contained a brief mention of the upcoming arbitration, noting that "J. Fairchild and E. Barlow shall present their respective evidence at the September meeting."

But when Lucy turned to the September section, she immediately spotted what had troubled Clara Beth. Several pages had been clearly removed—the cut edges still visible along the binding. The minutes jumped from September 10 to September 30, with no record of what had transpired during the crucial period when James Fairchild had died and the land dispute had apparently been resolved.

Even more telling, the September 30 minutes began mid-sentence, as if continuing a discussion that had been excised from the record:

"...therefore resolved without further testimony. Mr. Wells objects to the irregularity of proceedings but is overruled by majority vote. The northwestern boundary shall be recorded as per the revised survey, with Barlow property extending to include the full creek access."

Lucy sat back, processing what she'd found. Someone had deliberately removed portions of the official town records—specifically, the sections that would have detailed the dispute resolution process after James Fairchild's convenient death. And Jeremiah Wells, then the town's mayor, had apparently objected to something about the proceedings.

This had to be what Clara Beth discovered, and what she'd found confirmation of in Wells' personal journal. The "irregularity of proceedings" Wells had objected to might have been much more sinister than a procedural complaint.

"Find anything interesting?" Doris asked, appearing at Lucy's elbow.

Lucy jumped slightly. "Yes, actually. There appear to be pages missing from the September 1885 minutes."

"As I mentioned," Doris nodded. "Not uncommon with materials this old."

"But these pages weren't damaged or lost accidentally," Lucy pointed out. "They were deliberately cut out. Look at how clean the edges are—this was intentional."

Doris peered at the binding, frowning. "Well, I suppose that's possible. Though why anyone would remove town council minutes is beyond me."

"Unless those minutes contained something someone wanted erased from history," Lucy suggested.

Doris looked uncomfortable again. "That's quite an accusation, Lucy. These records have been in the archive for generations. Any alteration would have happened long ago."

"Exactly," Lucy agreed. "And that's what Clara Beth was trying to prove—that the historical record had been deliberately altered to hide something about that land dispute."

As Lucy continued through the records, she found more subtle alterations. In the property tax records from 1886, the entry for the Barlow property had clearly been amended, with the property value assessment significantly increased due to what was noted as "riparian rights"—the legal term for water access that came with owning land along the creek.

Those water rights had apparently been quite valuable. By 1890, Emmett Barlow had established a successful mill operation using the creek's water power, which tax records showed had substantially increased the family's wealth over the following decades.

It wasn't hard to connect the dots: a disputed property line, a suspicious death right before arbitration, missing council records, and a subsequent financial windfall for the Barlow family that set the foundation for generations of prosperity—including the bank that Frank Barlow now presided over.

As Lucy was preparing to leave, she noticed one more document that caught her attention—a slim folder labeled "Sheriff's Reports, 1885." Inside were monthly summaries from Sheriff Williams to the town council. The September report contained a brief mention of James Fairchild's death:

"Found deceased at his home, Sept. 22. Dr. Monroe attributes to heart failure. No signs of [word crossed out] forced entry. Dispute with E. Barlow noted but no evidence of [several words crossed out] foul play. Case closed."

The crossed-out words were tantalizing—someone had literally taken a pen to the official sheriff's report, redacting certain details. Lucy held the page up to the light, trying to make out what had been obscured, but the black ink was too thorough.

Armed with these discoveries, Lucy thanked Doris and hurried out of the archives. She needed to share what she'd found with Sheriff Pritchard. The historical alterations might not prove who had killed Clara Beth, but they established a clear motive: protecting a century-old family secret that had shaped Brentwood Falls' power structures.

She found Hank in his office at the sheriff's department, looking weary as he reviewed reports. He glanced up as she entered, his expression a mixture of resignation and concern.

"Let me guess," he said dryly. "You've been investigating instead of shelving books."

"I've been researching town history," Lucy clarified, taking the seat across from his desk. "Specifically, what Clara Beth was working on before she was killed."

Hank sighed, setting aside his paperwork. "Alright, I'm listening. What did our town librarian uncover that our trained investigators missed?"

Lucy explained her discoveries, from the newspaper articles about James Fairchild's suspicious death to the altered town records and the financial benefit the Barlow family had reaped from acquiring the creek property.

"Someone deliberately removed evidence of what really happened in 1885," she concluded. "And I think Clara Beth found proof of that in Jeremiah Wells' journal—proof that was dangerous enough to get her killed."

Hank listened attentively, making occasional notes. When she finished, he leaned back in his chair, considering.

"That's quite a theory," he said finally. "But you're connecting dots across a 140-year span and suggesting someone committed murder to protect a historical secret."

"Wouldn't be the first time," Lucy pointed out. "Family reputations and fortunes have been built on less."

"True," Hank acknowledged. "But we need evidence connecting these historical findings to Clara Beth's murder, not just speculation."

"What about the missing journal and the missing history book?" Lucy pressed. "Both contained evidence of historical tampering, and both disappeared around the time Clara Beth was killed."

"Circumstantial," Hank replied, though his expression suggested he was taking her seriously. "We haven't found either book yet, but we're following several leads."

"Have you questioned Frank Barlow about his meeting with Clara Beth at The Daily Grind last Thursday?"

Hank's eyebrows rose. "How do you know about that?"

"Hazel saw them," Lucy explained. "Clara Beth's appointment book confirmed she was presenting her findings to him before going public—giving him a chance to 'correct the record.' What if he decided silencing her was easier?"

"Lucy," Hank's voice took on a warning tone, "making accusations against the president of Brentwood Falls' only bank based on historical research and a café meeting is dangerous territory."

"I'm not accusing him," Lucy insisted. "I'm pointing out connections that can't be coincidental. Clara Beth discovers evidence that the Barlow family's wealth was built on a suspicious death and altered records. She meets with Frank Barlow. Days later, she's murdered right before revealing her discoveries publicly, and the key evidence disappears."

Hank rubbed his temples. "Look, I'm not dismissing your findings. They establish potential motive. But we need more than motive to make an arrest."

"What about opportunity? Frank Barlow has access to the library after hours as a board member. He could have removed 'Foundation and Growth' after Tilly returned it."

"Again, circumstantial," Hank replied. "Half the town had access to the library during regular hours."

Lucy huffed in frustration. "So we just wait while a murderer walks free?"

"No," Hank said firmly. "We investigate methodically. I'll look into Frank Barlow's whereabouts during the time of Clara Beth's murder, and we'll keep searching for those missing books." He fixed her with a stern look. "In the meantime, please try not to antagonize potential murder suspects with accusations about their ancestors."

Lucy left the sheriff's department feeling both validated and frustrated. Hank was taking her discoveries seriously, but the investigation was moving too slowly for her liking. Clara Beth's killer was still out there, potentially destroying more evidence even now.

Her next stop was The Brentwood Antiquarian, the town's only bookstore specializing in rare and historical volumes. Its owner, Jed Forrester, was a history enthusiast who had occasionally collaborated with Clara Beth on local history projects.

The bell above the door jingled as Lucy entered the cozy shop. Shelves overflowing with leather-bound books lined the walls, and the air smelled pleasantly of old paper and wood polish. Jed appeared from the back room, his round face lighting up in recognition.

"Lucy! What brings our librarian to the commercial side of the literary world? Looking for something the budget committee won't approve?"

"Actually, I'm here about Clara Beth," Lucy replied. "I understand you two worked together sometimes on historical research."

Jed's smile faded. "Terrible business, that. I still can't believe someone would... well, in our town, of all places."

"Did Clara Beth mention what she was working on recently? Something about altered historical records?"

Jed's bushy eyebrows rose. "As a matter of fact, yes. She was quite animated about it when she came in last month. Said she'd found evidence that someone had systematically modified Brentwood Falls' historical narrative." He lowered his voice conspiratorially. "Between us, she was convinced it went beyond simple historical revision—called it a 'deliberate cover-up of something criminal.'"

"Did she mention what specifically?" Lucy asked eagerly.

"Something about a land dispute and a suspicious death in the 1880s," Jed recalled, stroking his goatee thoughtfully. "She was particularly frustrated with missing records—said she needed to find original sources that hadn't been 'sanitized.'"

"Like Jeremiah Wells' personal journal?"

"Exactly!" Jed nodded enthusiastically. "She was thrilled when she tracked that down. Came in about two weeks ago to tell me about it—said it contained the unfiltered truth about Brentwood Falls' founding families." His expression fell. "She promised to show it to me after the book fair."

"Did she mention the book 'Foundation and Growth'?" Lucy asked. "Specifically the footnotes?"

"Yes, actually. She believed someone had altered the footnotes in the library's copy to change certain historical details." Jed frowned. "In fact, she asked if I had another copy she could compare against, but first editions of local histories are quite rare."

Lucy's pulse quickened. "Jed, this is important—do you remember if she mentioned anything specific about those footnotes? Any particular pattern or code?"

Jed thought for a moment. "She did say something odd. That sometimes 'the truth is hidden in plain sight' and that 'careful readers find messages between the lines.' I assumed it was just Clara Beth being poetically academic, as was her way."

"Messages between the lines," Lucy repeated thoughtfully. "Or within the footnotes themselves..."

Something was tugging at the edges of her memory—something Clara Beth had once told her about how historians sometimes hid controversial information in plain sight. What if the footnotes themselves contained a message beyond their apparent content?

"One more thing," Lucy said. "Did Clara Beth ever mention the Barlow family specifically? Or Frank Barlow?"

A shadow seemed to cross Jed's face. "Not to me directly. But I did overhear her on the phone once, saying something like 'the Barlow fortune was built on stolen land and worse.' She noticed me listening and quickly changed the subject." He hesitated. "Lucy, you don't think Frank Barlow had something to do with what happened to Clara Beth, do you?"

"I'm just following the evidence," Lucy replied carefully. "Thank you for your help, Jed."

As Lucy left the bookstore, her mind was working overtime. Clara Beth had discovered something in the footnotes of "Foundation and Growth"—something beyond the simple alterations Tilly had noticed. Messages between the lines. The truth hidden in plain sight.

She hurried back to the library, making straight for her office. Tilly's photocopies of the suspicious footnotes were still locked in her desk drawer. Lucy spread them out, studying them with fresh eyes.

The altered footnotes about the land dispute were interesting, but what if there was more to them? Clara Beth had said Jeremiah Wells kept dual records—the official version in the main text and the unvarnished truth in his marginalia.

Lucy examined each footnote carefully, looking for patterns or hidden meanings. Nothing obvious jumped out. Then she remembered something else from her conversation with Tilly—Clara Beth had specifically directed the reporter to check the footnotes when "official history seems too tidy."

She dug through her bag for her notes from Clara Beth's research journal. The historian's final entry had mentioned that "the footnotes were right all along—you just needed to know how to read them."

How to read them. Not just what they said, but how they were constructed.

Lucy rifled through her desk until she found what she was looking for—a book on historical research methods that Clara Beth had given her years ago. She flipped to the chapter on analyzing primary sources, scanning until she found the section on coded messages and acrostics.

"That's it," she whispered to the empty office.

She returned to the photocopied footnotes with renewed purpose. Ignoring the content, she focused instead on the form—specifically, the first letter of each sentence within the longer footnotes.

In a footnote about town governance during the 1880s, the first letters spelled out: M-U-R-D-E-R-E-D.

Lucy's hands trembled as she checked another footnote, this one about economic development in early Brentwood Falls. The first letters of its sentences: F-A-I-R-C-H-I-L-D.

"Murdered Fairchild," Lucy breathed. "Clara Beth found a coded message in the footnotes."

She quickly checked the other photocopied footnotes, but many were too short or had been altered, breaking whatever pattern might have been there originally. She needed the complete book to decode the full message—the book that had mysteriously disappeared after Clara Beth's research.

Lucy sat back, her heart racing. Clara Beth had discovered a hidden confession embedded in the footnotes of "Foundation and Growth"—likely placed there by Jeremiah Wells himself as a way to record the truth without openly accusing anyone. The historian had then found confirmation in Wells' personal journal, giving her proof of what really happened to James Fairchild in 1885.

But without either book, Lucy couldn't prove what Clara Beth had discovered. She couldn't even determine the full message Jeremiah Wells had hidden in the footnotes.

She closed her eyes, thinking furiously. If Clara Beth had found this code, she would have documented it somewhere. Her research journal at home had mentioned the footnotes but not the specific code. Where else might she have kept notes about this discovery?

Then it hit her—Clara Beth's workspace at the Historical Society. She'd checked the historical files but hadn't thoroughly examined the desk itself. What if Clara Beth had left notes there about the coded footnotes?

Lucy glanced at her watch. The Historical Society would be closing soon, but if she hurried, she might have time for one more search. She gathered her materials, locking the photocopies safely in her drawer before heading out.

As she left the library, Lucy couldn't shake the feeling that she was getting dangerously close to the truth—the same truth that had cost Clara Beth her life. Someone in Brentwood Falls was desperate to keep the past buried, desperate enough to commit murder.

The question was, would Lucy find the proof before the killer found her?

6

The evening sky was darkening as Lucy pulled up to the Brentwood Falls Gazette office. The small, two-story brick building housed not just the town's weekly newspaper but also several professional offices—a local insurance agent, a tax preparer, and a part-time therapist who specialized in "rural mindfulness," whatever that meant.

The newspaper itself occupied the entirety of the first floor, though "occupied" might have been generous phrasing. With a full-time staff of exactly three people—editor-in-chief Harold Winters, photographer/sports reporter Jimmy Dawson, and ace reporter/everything else Tilly Harper—the Gazette hardly needed sprawling facilities.

Lucy found Tilly at her desk, surrounded by stacks of paper and empty coffee cups, furiously typing at a keyboard that had seen better days. The journalist didn't look up until Lucy cleared her throat.

"Lucy!" Tilly startled, quickly minimizing whatever was on her screen. "What brings you here after hours? Please tell me the library budget hasn't been cut again."

"Not a budget emergency this time," Lucy replied, pulling up a spare chair. "I need to talk to you about Clara Beth."

Tilly's expression shifted, caution replacing her usual energetic curiosity. "I've already told you everything I know."

"I don't think you have," Lucy said gently. "You're working on a story about her research, aren't you?"

Tilly's eyes widened slightly. "What makes you think that?"

"Because Clara Beth promised you 'the biggest story you'd ever cover in Brentwood Falls,' and you're not the type to let that go, even after her death." Lucy leaned forward. "Especially after her death."

Tilly sat back in her chair, conflict evident on her face. After a moment's hesitation, she reached into a drawer and pulled out a thick manila folder.

"I was going to call you, actually," she admitted. "Once I'd figured out what to do with all of this."

"All of what?"

Tilly opened the folder to reveal pages of notes, photocopies, and what appeared to be transcribed interviews. "Clara Beth had been feeding me information for weeks. Building the story piece by piece. She wanted everything thoroughly documented before publication."

"Publication of what exactly?" Lucy asked, leaning forward to examine the materials.

"A bombshell exposé," Tilly replied, lowering her voice despite the empty office. "About how one of Brentwood Falls' most respected families built their fortune on murder, theft, and historical fraud."

Lucy's heart quickened. "The Barlows."

Tilly nodded. "Clara Beth was convinced that Emmett Barlow murdered James Fairchild in 1885 to gain control of valuable creek-front property, then systematically altered the historical record to hide the crime."

"I found evidence of altered town records," Lucy told her. "And suspicious edit marks in the sheriff's report from 1885. But that's all circumstantial—it doesn't prove murder."

"Which is why Clara Beth was so excited about finding Jeremiah Wells' journal," Tilly explained. "She believed it contained direct testimony about what really happened." She hesitated, then added: "She also found something in 'Foundation and Growth' that she called 'hidden proof in plain sight.'"

"The coded footnotes," Lucy breathed. "First letters spelling out 'murdered Fairchild.'"

Tilly's eyebrows shot up. "You found that too? I thought I was going crazy when I noticed it. Some of the footnotes seemed to have these strange patterns."

"Clara Beth told you about this?"

"Not directly. She just kept saying I needed to 'read between the lines' and 'look for patterns in the notes.' It wasn't until after..." Tilly swallowed hard. "After what happened, that I went back through my copies and started seeing the patterns."

"May I?" Lucy gestured to the folder.

Tilly hesitated only briefly before pushing it toward her. "I'm trusting you with this, Lucy. I haven't even told Harold about the full story yet. Clara Beth wanted everything verified before we published."

Lucy carefully leafed through Tilly's materials. Most were items she'd already discovered—the newspaper articles about Fairchild's death, notes about altered records, theories about the land dispute. But then she came across something she hadn't seen before—a photocopy of what appeared to be a handwritten letter, the paper yellowed with age and the ink faded.

"What's this?"

"Clara Beth found it last month in the Fairchild family papers at the county historical archive," Tilly explained. "It's a letter from Elizabeth Fairchild—James's widow—to her sister a month after his death."

Lucy read the letter carefully:

Dearest Mary,

I cannot say openly what I suspect, as E.B. has friends in every office in town. The sheriff will not listen, and Mayor Wells, though sympathetic, says there is no proof beyond my word against his. But I know what James told me the night before—that he had finally found the original survey maps proving our claim. Those maps were nowhere to be found after his "heart failure," nor were the letters from the prior owner confirming our boundaries.

I fear we shall lose everything to a man who would stop at nothing to get what he desires. The creek access alone will make him the wealthiest man in the county within a decade, while my children and I are left to survive on charity.

Yours in grief, Elizabeth

"This is extraordinary," Lucy murmured. "A contemporary accusation from Elizabeth Fairchild herself."

"Not enough to prove murder, as you said," Tilly noted. "But combined with the altered records and the coded footnotes..."

"It builds a compelling case," Lucy agreed. "But why would Frank Barlow kill to protect a 140-year-old family secret? The statute of limitations on murder would have expired generations ago."

"That's where it gets interesting," Tilly said, pulling out another document. "Clara Beth wasn't just investigating the historical crime. She believed the original crime had led to ongoing fraud." She handed Lucy what appeared to be a property record. "The creek-front land that Emmett Barlow acquired after Fairchild's death? It's now the site of Barlow Estate."

Lucy's eyes widened. "Frank Barlow's mansion?"

"And the land directly adjacent to it, which houses the First Brentwood Bank headquarters," Tilly added. "Both built on property that, according to Clara Beth's research, was fraudulently acquired through murder and document falsification."

"But that was so long ago," Lucy protested. "Surely the property has been legally bought and sold many times since then."

"That's just it," Tilly said, excitement bleeding into her voice despite the serious subject. "According to land records, the original creek parcel has never left Barlow family hands. It's been directly passed down from Emmett to his son to his grandson to Frank. Never sold, never subdivided, never subject to proper legal scrutiny."

"So if the original claim was fraudulent..."

"Then technically, the Barlows have never legally owned that land," Tilly finished. "Clara Beth believed that the rightful ownership would revert to Fairchild descendants if the truth came to light."

"My goodness," Lucy breathed. "That would mean the bank headquarters⁠—"

"Is built on stolen property," Tilly nodded vigorously. "And under state banking regulations, a bank must own its headquarters building outright or face major regulatory consequences. If Frank Barlow's claim to that land was invalidated..."

"The bank could be at risk," Lucy concluded. "No wonder he was desperate to stop Clara Beth."

Tilly pulled out one more item from her folder—a small notepad with Clara Beth's distinctive handwriting. "She gave me this for safekeeping last Wednesday. Said it was 'insurance' in case anything happened to her research materials."

Lucy took the notepad with trembling hands. Each page contained meticulous notes about the coded messages hidden in the footnotes of "Foundation and Growth." Clara Beth had carefully documented which footnotes contained the hidden text and how they spelled out various phrases:

MURDERED FAIRCHILD FOR CREEK ACCESS EMMETT BARLOW GUILTY WELLS KNEW TRUTH

On the final page was a cryptic note: "Complete confession hidden in margins. JW was too clever to be silenced—he left proof in plain sight for those who knew where to look."

"The margins," Lucy muttered. "Not just the footnotes, but the actual margins of the journal."

"That's what I think she meant," Tilly agreed. "That Wells wrote his true account in the margins of his personal journal—the one she found and was so excited about."

"The one that's now missing," Lucy said grimly. "Along with 'Foundation and Growth.'"

"Exactly." Tilly hesitated. "Lucy, I've been thinking—what if whoever took those books doesn't know about the coded messages? What if they just removed them thinking that would be enough to hide the truth?"

"Then Clara Beth's notes might be the only remaining evidence," Lucy realized. "Which means you could still publish the story."

"With a murdered source and no primary documents?" Tilly shook her head. "Harold would never approve it. We'd be opening ourselves up to libel suits from one of the most powerful families in the county."

"But you have her research," Lucy insisted. "Her notes, the letter from Elizabeth Fairchild, the property records..."

"All circumstantial," Tilly sighed. "Just like you told me before. Without those books—especially Wells' journal with the marginal notes—it's just speculation based on patterns and coincidences."

Lucy sat back, frustration evident in her posture. "So the killer gets away with both murders—James Fairchild's and Clara Beth's—because the primary evidence is missing?"

"Unless we can find those books," Tilly said. "Or some other concrete proof of what Clara Beth discovered."

Lucy's mind was racing. "There might be another way. Clara Beth was methodical—she wouldn't have kept all her evidence in one place. What if there's something in her belongings that we missed?"

"The police have already searched her home," Tilly pointed out.

"Yes, but they were looking for evidence of her murder, not proof of a historical crime," Lucy countered. "And I've been to her house, too, but I didn't know what I was looking for. Now I do—something about 'hidden proof in the margins.'"

Tilly looked thoughtful. "I suppose it's worth another look. But be careful, Lucy. If Frank Barlow really did kill Clara Beth to protect this secret..."

"I know," Lucy nodded grimly. "I'd be putting myself in danger by pursuing it."

As they gathered the materials, Lucy noticed something odd about one of the photocopied pages from "Foundation and Growth"—a small annotation in Clara Beth's handwriting that she'd missed before. In the margin next to a particularly long footnote, Clara Beth had written: "Check library copy pg. 187—hidden reference to original map location?"

"Tilly, did Clara Beth ever mention page 187 specifically?"

The journalist frowned, thinking. "Not that I recall. Why?"

"She made a note about it here," Lucy pointed to the annotation. "Something about a hidden reference to an original map location."

"Map location?" Tilly's eyes widened. "Like where the original survey maps might be hidden?"

"Maybe," Lucy said excitedly. "The letter from Elizabeth Fairchild mentioned missing survey maps that proved their boundary claim."

"If those original maps still exist somewhere..."

"They would be definitive proof," Lucy finished. "Concrete evidence that couldn't be dismissed as coincidence or pattern-seeking."

Tilly quickly searched through her notes. "I don't see anything else about page 187 or maps. But Clara Beth was keeping some things close to the vest—said she'd reveal everything once she had the final pieces in place."

Lucy checked her watch—almost 8 PM. "It's too late to visit Clara Beth's house again tonight. But first thing tomorrow, I'm going to check every margin and notebook I can find."

"Do you want company?" Tilly offered. "Two sets of eyes are better than one."

"Thanks, but it might be better if you focus on organizing what we already have," Lucy suggested. "And maybe check if the Gazette archives have any other articles about the Fairchild-Barlow dispute that Clara Beth might have missed."

As they parted ways outside the Gazette office, Lucy felt both energized by their discoveries and unsettled by their implications. If Frank Barlow had killed Clara Beth to protect his family's fraudulent claim to the land that now housed both his mansion and the bank headquarters, he'd be equally motivated to silence anyone else who got too close to the truth.

She needed to be careful.

The next morning, Lucy arrived at the library early, hoping for some quiet time to gather her thoughts before the day's patrons arrived. To her surprise, she found Jeremy Collins, their part-time page, already sorting books at the circulation desk.

"Jeremy! You're in early today."

The college student looked up with a tired smile. "Yeah, I'm covering for Marge this morning. She has a doctor's appointment."

"That's right," Lucy nodded, vaguely remembering that arrangement. "How are your classes going?"

"Good, mostly. Though my history professor is pretty demanding." Jeremy shelved a few more books before adding casually, "By the way, Mr. Barlow was looking for you yesterday afternoon."

Lucy froze. "Frank Barlow was here? Looking for me specifically?"

"Yeah, seemed pretty intent on finding you. When I told him you were out, he asked a bunch of questions about when you'd be back and what you'd been working on lately." Jeremy frowned slightly. "He even asked if you'd mentioned Clara Beth's research to me. Kinda weird."

"What did you tell him?" Lucy asked, trying to keep her voice casual.

"Just that you don't really discuss your personal research with the student help," Jeremy shrugged. "He hung around for a while, though. Seemed... I don't know, agitated? Not his usual banker self."

A chill ran down Lucy's spine. Frank Barlow was clearly worried about what she might know—worried enough to come looking for her and question her staff.

"Did he go anywhere specific in the library while he was waiting?"

Jeremy thought for a moment. "Actually, yeah. He went to your office for a bit. Said he needed to check on something for the next board meeting."

"My office?" Lucy repeated sharply. "Jeremy, did you let him into my office?"

"Well, yeah," the student replied, looking confused by her reaction. "He's on the library board. I didn't think it was a big deal."

Lucy hurried to her office, heart pounding. The room appeared undisturbed at first glance, but when she checked the drawer where she'd locked Tilly's photocopies, she found it slightly ajar. The copies were still there, but had they been examined? Photographed? She had no way of knowing.

More concerning was what this meant—Frank Barlow was actively investigating her investigation. The hunter had become aware of another hunter on his trail.

As Lucy was processing this disturbing development, the library phone rang. Jeremy answered at the circulation desk, then called out, "Lucy, it's for you. Mrs. Martinez from the Historical Society."

Lucy picked up the extension in her office. "This is Lucy."

"Lucy, dear," came the breathless voice of Eleanor Martinez, the Historical Society's elderly volunteer coordinator. "I was just organizing the visitor log as Walter asked, and I remembered something I thought you should know."

"What is it, Eleanor?"

"Last week—Tuesday, I believe—Mr. Barlow from the bank came to see Clara Beth in her office. I wouldn't have thought much of it, except..."

"Except what?" Lucy prompted when the woman paused.

"Well, they had quite a heated discussion. I couldn't hear everything, but Clara Beth's voice was raised, which was most unlike her. She said something about 'the truth coming out no matter who tries to hide it.' When Mr. Barlow left, he looked... well, furious is the only word for it."

Tuesday—two days before the café meeting Hazel had witnessed, and just three days before Clara Beth's murder at the book fair.

"Did Clara Beth say anything about their discussion afterward?" Lucy asked.

"Only that some people valued their reputations more than historical accuracy," Eleanor replied. "She seemed shaken, though. I offered her tea, but she said she needed to secure some documents instead."

Secure documents. Lucy's mind immediately went to the missing books and the cryptic note about "hidden proof in the margins."

"Thank you, Eleanor. That's very helpful."

"There's one more thing," the elderly volunteer added. "The day after that meeting, I came in early and found Clara Beth's office light on. When I checked, I found Mr. Barlow himself there, claiming he'd forgotten some papers during his meeting. Clara Beth wasn't in yet, and Walter had given him access. Nothing seemed disturbed, but..." She paused. "Well, in light of what's happened, I thought you should know."

Lucy's blood ran cold. Frank Barlow had been searching Clara Beth's office at the Historical Society—just as he'd apparently searched Lucy's office at the library. He was systematically hunting down every trace of Clara Beth's research.

"Eleanor, this is important—has anyone been through Clara Beth's things at the Society since her death?"

"Walter's been keeping her office locked until we decide how to handle her materials," Eleanor assured her. "Though Mr. Barlow did suggest to the board that he would be happy to 'sort through her financial records' as a service. The board hasn't decided yet."

Of course he had. Frank Barlow was methodically eliminating every possible source of evidence about his family's dark secret.

"Please ask Walter to keep everything locked and untouched," Lucy urged. "It's potentially relevant to the police investigation."

After hanging up, Lucy sat at her desk, thoughts racing. Frank Barlow had argued with Clara Beth at the Historical Society, then returned to search her office when she wasn't there. He'd met with her at The Daily Grind in what now appeared to be a confrontation rather than a simple conversation. And after her murder, he'd searched Lucy's office as well.

The circumstantial evidence was mounting, but Lucy still lacked definitive proof connecting Frank to Clara Beth's murder—or concrete evidence of the historical crime that had started it all.

"Page 187," she murmured, remembering Clara Beth's annotation. "Hidden reference to original map location."

Lucy was getting closer to the truth, but she was also attracting very unwanted attention. Frank Barlow knew she was investigating, and if he was indeed Clara Beth's killer, Lucy had just moved to the top of his threat list.

She needed to find those missing books—and quickly.

7

Lucy had never been particularly fond of confrontation. As a librarian, she preferred to solve problems through research, organization, and the occasional well-timed shushing. But as she drove her modest sedan through the imposing wrought-iron gates of the Barlow estate, she knew that sometimes information couldn't be found in books alone.

The Barlow mansion stood at the highest point of what locals still called "Creek Hill," though the actual creek now ran discreetly through professionally landscaped grounds. The house itself was an architectural testament to old money—colonial revival with classic columns, perfectly symmetrical windows, and a circular driveway that currently held Lucy's car like an awkward afterthought among the manicured perfection.

"This is either very brave or very stupid," she muttered to herself as she retrieved her tote bag from the passenger seat. Inside, disguised among library committee documents, were copies of Tilly's notes and Clara Beth's annotations.

She'd called ahead, ostensibly to discuss the upcoming library fundraiser that Frank Barlow's wife, Margaret, co-chaired each year. It was flimsy pretext at best, but Lucy was counting on social politeness to get her in the door. After that...well, she was making this up as she went along.

A stern-faced housekeeper answered her ring, eying Lucy's sensible cardigan and practical flats with barely concealed judgment.

"Ms. Blackstone for Mr. Barlow," Lucy said, summoning her most professional smile. "I believe he's expecting me."

The housekeeper's expression suggested that being expected and being welcome were two very different things, but she stepped aside. "Mr. Barlow is in his study. This way, please."

Lucy followed, taking careful note of her surroundings. The Barlow home was exactly what one would expect from a banker's mansion—tastefully expensive in that way that never had to announce its cost, with antique furniture, original artwork, and the distinct absence of anything that might be sold at a store where regular people shopped.

The housekeeper led her down a hallway adorned with family portraits. Lucy slowed briefly, noting the progression of Barlow patriarchs through the decades, each man bearing the same straight nose and determined jaw. At the end hung a portrait of Emmett Barlow himself, stern-faced and prosperous in late-19th century finery, one hand resting on what appeared to be a property deed.

The symbolism wasn't subtle.

The housekeeper rapped sharply on a set of double doors before announcing, "Ms. Blackstone to see you, sir."

Frank Barlow looked up from behind an antique desk that probably cost more than Lucy's annual salary. His momentary surprise quickly shifted to wary calculation.

"Lucy. This is unexpected." Despite his words, Lucy noted he didn't seem particularly surprised. "Margaret mentioned you might be stopping by about the fundraiser, though I thought you'd be meeting at the committee room."

"The committee room was booked for the garden club," Lucy improvised. "And since we needed to go over some financial details, I thought it would be more efficient to come directly to you." She smiled pleasantly. "I hope I'm not interrupting anything important."

"Not at all," Frank replied with a banker's professional courtesy that didn't quite reach his eyes. "Please, have a seat."

As the housekeeper withdrew, closing the doors behind her, Lucy took the opportunity to survey the study. It was a bibliophile's dream—walls lined with built-in bookshelves from floor to ceiling, interrupted only by a massive stone fireplace and tall windows overlooking the property. A rolling library ladder provided access to the highest shelves, and comfortable leather reading chairs created cozy nooks throughout the space.

What immediately caught Lucy's attention, however, was a glass-fronted display case on the far wall. Unlike the open bookshelves, this case was locked, its contents carefully arranged behind protective glass. Even from across the room, Lucy could tell these were rare volumes—leather-bound, ancient-looking, and very deliberately secured.

"Your library is magnificent," she said truthfully, moving toward the shelves. "I had no idea you were such a collector."

"A family tradition," Frank replied, watching her movements carefully. "The Barlows have always valued the preservation of knowledge."

"Selective preservation, perhaps," Lucy thought but didn't say.

"Some of these volumes must be quite valuable," she continued aloud, casually making her way toward the locked display case.

"Primarily of sentimental value," Frank replied smoothly, rising from his desk. "Now, about the fundraiser⁠—"

"Are these first editions?" Lucy asked, now standing directly before the case, examining its contents with genuine interest. Inside were perhaps two dozen volumes, all antique and clearly valuable. Her trained librarian's eye scanned the titles, looking for anything related to Brentwood Falls history.

"Family heirlooms, mostly," Frank said, moving to stand beside her. "My ancestors were meticulous about preserving local historical materials."

"I can see that," Lucy nodded, her heart suddenly racing as her gaze fell on a familiar leather spine in the center of the bottom shelf. Though partially obscured by other books, she could just make out a gold-embossed title: "Foundation and Growth: A Historical Account of Brentwood Falls."

It couldn't be coincidence. The missing library book was here, locked in Frank Barlow's private collection.

"This is an impressive historical section," Lucy commented, keeping her voice casual with effort. "I imagine Clara Beth Jennings would have loved to see these volumes."

Frank's shoulder twitched almost imperceptibly at Clara Beth's name. "Perhaps. Though Clara Beth had some rather unorthodox theories about local history."

"Oh?" Lucy turned to face him directly. "What kind of theories?"

"Nothing worth discussing," Frank replied dismissively. "Historical speculation without adequate documentation—the kind of thing that can unfairly damage reputations built over generations."

"Speaking of historical documentation," Lucy continued, deciding to take a risk, "I've been researching the northwestern boundary settlement of 1885 for our local history collection. It seems there was some dispute between the Fairchild and Barlow families over creek access."

Frank's expression hardened almost imperceptibly. "Ancient history. Boundary disputes were common in those days, before modern surveying techniques."

"Of course," Lucy nodded agreeably. "Though this particular dispute seems to have resolved quite suddenly after James Fairchild's unexpected death. His widow apparently contested the outcome."

Frank's hand moved to his tie, adjusting it slightly—the same nervous tell Lucy had noticed during their conversation at the bank. "Historical records from that period are notoriously incomplete. Family legends often fill the gaps with... colorful interpretations."

"That's why primary sources are so valuable," Lucy replied, turning back to the locked case. "Original documents and contemporaneous accounts provide the clearest picture of what really happened."

She let her gaze linger pointedly on the partially visible "Foundation and Growth" volume. "Some historians believe there are hidden truths in historical footnotes—coded messages that reveal what couldn't be stated openly at the time."

Frank's demeanor shifted from wary to tense. "That sounds like the kind of fanciful thinking Clara Beth was prone to. Historical documents should be taken at face value, not mined for conspiracy theories."

"Is it a conspiracy theory to question why pages were removed from town council minutes?" Lucy asked, abandoning pretense. "Or why sheriff's reports had words crossed out? Or why a valuable creek property suddenly changed hands after its owner died under convenient circumstances?"

Frank's face flushed. "I think we're straying rather far from library fundraising, Ms. Blackstone."

"You're right," Lucy acknowledged. "I apologize. Professional hazard—I get carried away with historical research." She smiled thinly. "Like Clara Beth, I suppose."

The temperature in the room seemed to drop several degrees. Frank moved back to his desk, putting distance between them.

"I'm afraid I have another appointment shortly," he said, his voice now clipped and formal. "Perhaps you should coordinate with Margaret directly about fundraiser details."

"Of course," Lucy replied, noting how his hands trembled slightly as he shuffled papers on his desk. "I appreciate your time, Mr. Barlow. Your family history is... enlightening."

She turned to leave, but paused at the door. "One last question, if you don't mind. Did you know that Jeremiah Wells kept coded messages in his personal journal? Clara Beth found quite a revelation there."

It was a bluff—she had no idea exactly what Clara Beth had found in Wells' journal. But Frank's reaction told her everything. His face went ashen, and for a moment, the composed banker disappeared, replaced by something Lucy had never seen before: raw fear.

"I have no idea what you're talking about," he managed finally. "Good day, Ms. Blackstone."

As the housekeeper escorted her out, Lucy knew two things with absolute certainty: "Foundation and Growth" was locked in Frank Barlow's display case, and her probing questions had touched a very sensitive nerve.

She'd also just made herself an unmistakable threat to whatever Frank was hiding.

The drive back to town gave Lucy time to organize her thoughts. She now had confirmation that at least one of the missing books was in Frank's possession. The second—Wells' personal journal—might also be there, though she hadn't been able to identify it among the other volumes in the locked case.

She needed to tell Sheriff Pritchard, but what exactly could she report? That she'd seen what looked like a library book in Frank Barlow's private collection? Without being able to examine it up close, she couldn't even be certain it was the library's copy rather than another edition.

And even if it was, Frank could simply claim he'd purchased it legitimately or had his own copy all along. The presence of the book in his house wasn't proof of theft, let alone murder.

Lucy pulled into the library parking lot just as the afternoon shadows were lengthening. Her head was spinning with theories and possibilities, but she needed hard evidence before taking her suspicions to Hank.

The library was quiet when she entered, with just a few patrons browsing the stacks. Marge looked up from the circulation desk with relief.

"There you are! I was about to call. You have a delivery." She pointed to a small package sitting on the counter.

"A delivery? I wasn't expecting anything."

"It came by courier about an hour ago," Marge explained. "Addressed specifically to you, not the library."

Lucy examined the plain brown-paper package. It was book-shaped and roughly the size of a hardcover novel, with no return address or identifying markings besides her name printed in block letters. A sense of unease crept over her as she picked it up.

"Did you see who delivered it?"

"Some service I didn't recognize," Marge shrugged. "The delivery person was just a youngster in a uniform. Said it needed to be placed directly in your hands, but I told him you were out."

Lucy carried the package to her office, closing the door before carefully unwrapping it. Inside was a book—but not either of the missing volumes she'd been hoping for. Instead, it was a modern true crime paperback about historical murders. A plain white bookmark protruded from between the pages.

When Lucy opened to the marked page, her blood ran cold. The chapter was titled "Getting Away With Murder," and someone had underlined a single sentence: "The most dangerous moment for investigators is when they get too close to the truth."

A small note card fell from between the pages. In the same block printing as the address label, it read simply: "DROP IT, OR YOU'LL BE NEXT."

Lucy stared at the message, her hands trembling slightly. This was no longer theoretical danger. Someone—almost certainly Frank Barlow—was directly threatening her life.

Her first instinct was to call Sheriff Pritchard immediately. But then what? She still lacked proof connecting Frank to Clara Beth's murder or the theft of the historical books. The threatening note contained no signature, no fingerprints besides her own, and could have been sent by anyone.

Lucy carefully placed the book, bookmark, and note in a clear plastic bag—preserving any potential evidence without adding more fingerprints. Then she called the one person she knew would understand the significance of what she'd found.

"Tilly? Can you meet me at The Daily Grind in twenty minutes? Bring everything you have on Clara Beth's research. I've found something important—and received a direct threat."

Hazel took one look at Lucy's face when she entered the café and immediately switched from proprietor mode to concerned friend.

"What happened?" she demanded, showing Lucy to a corner table well away from the few afternoon customers. "You look like you've seen a ghost."

"Not a ghost," Lucy replied grimly, "just a killer getting nervous." She showed Hazel the threatening note while keeping the plastic bag under the table.

"That tears it," Hazel declared after reading the message. "We're calling Hank right now."

"Not yet," Lucy countered. "I need something more concrete first. I saw 'Foundation and Growth' in Frank Barlow's locked display case."

"You broke into his house?" Hazel's voice rose in alarm.

"Of course not! I visited openly, on the pretext of discussing the library fundraiser."

"And then casually mentioned you suspected his ancestor of murder and document theft?" Hazel shook her head in disbelief. "No wonder someone's threatening you!"

"I didn't accuse anyone of anything," Lucy defended herself. "I simply asked some pointed questions about historical records."

"Pointed enough to earn you a death threat," Hazel retorted. "Lucy, this has gone far enough. Clara Beth was murdered. Now someone's threatening you. This isn't a cozy mystery where the amateur sleuth outsmarts everyone—this is real danger."

Before Lucy could respond, Tilly arrived, slightly out of breath and clutching her messenger bag. Her eyes widened at the sight of the threatening note.

"This changes everything," she declared after Lucy explained what had happened. "We need to go public with what we know—immediately."

"Without proof?" Lucy shook her head. "Frank would just deny everything, and we'd be opening ourselves up to libel suits, as you pointed out before."

"That was before he threatened you," Tilly countered. "This is escalating quickly."

"Exactly why we need to be strategic," Lucy insisted. "I saw 'Foundation and Growth' in his study. If we can prove it's the library's copy, and that it contains the coded footnotes Clara Beth discovered..."

"And how exactly do you plan to examine a book locked in a glass case in a potential murderer's private study?" Hazel demanded.

Lucy hesitated. "I'm... working on that part."

"While you 'work on that part,' someone is actively threatening to kill you," Hazel pointed out. "I'm calling Hank."

"Wait," Lucy held up a hand. "If we go to Hank now, what can he actually do? The threatening note isn't signed. The book in Frank's study could be his own copy. We'd just be creating a lot of noise without any actionable evidence."

"So what's your brilliant alternative?" Hazel asked.

Lucy drew a deep breath. "I think I know where to find the missing Wells journal—the one that would provide definitive proof of what happened to James Fairchild."

Both Tilly and Hazel leaned forward.

"Remember Clara Beth's note about 'hidden proof in the margins'? And her annotation about page 187 containing a reference to 'original map location'?" Lucy continued. "Clara Beth was methodical. She wouldn't have relied on just the books to preserve the evidence. She would have created backup documentation."

"We've been through her house and the Historical Society," Tilly pointed out. "Nothing."

"That's because we were looking in obvious places," Lucy explained. "But Clara Beth knew someone might search her belongings if her research became dangerous. She would have hidden her most important backup somewhere unexpected—somewhere only someone following her specific clues would think to look."

"And you think you know where that is?" Hazel asked skeptically.

"Page 187," Lucy replied. "But not in 'Foundation and Growth.' In the library catalog."

Tilly's eyes lit with understanding. "Dewey Decimal System—187 would be in philosophy and ethics."

"Exactly," Lucy nodded. "I think Clara Beth hid something in the 187 section of the library—something that would lead us to the original evidence she discovered."

"That's... actually brilliant," Tilly admitted. "Hidden in plain sight, in a place she knew you would eventually think to check."

"It's worth investigating," Lucy agreed. "But I need to do it discreetly. If Frank realizes we're getting close to the proof..."

"He might make good on his threat," Hazel finished grimly.

"Which is why I need you two to run interference," Lucy explained. "Hazel, if anyone asks, I've gone home with a migraine. Tilly, I need you to keep digging through the Gazette archives for anything else about the Fairchild-Barlow dispute. The more supporting evidence we have, the better."

"And what are you going to do?" Hazel asked, though her tone suggested she already knew and didn't like the answer.

"I'm going back to the library after hours," Lucy replied. "To check Dewey Decimal section 187 very, very thoroughly."

"Alone?" Hazel's voice rose in alarm. "After receiving a death threat?"

"The library is the safest place I could be," Lucy reasoned. "I have the only set of keys, the security system is modern, and every entry point is visible from the street. Anyone trying to get in would be immediately obvious."

Neither Hazel nor Tilly looked convinced.

"At least tell Hank about the threat," Hazel pleaded. "He could have a deputy keep an eye on the library without knowing exactly what you're doing."

Lucy considered this compromise. "Fine. I'll call him on my way back to the library. But I'm not explaining about the Dewey Decimal theory until I know if I'm right. The last thing we need is official interference before we have solid evidence."

As she left The Daily Grind, Lucy felt the weight of the plastic bag containing the threatening note in her tote. Someone had directly warned her to drop her investigation or suffer Clara Beth's fate. Logic and self-preservation suggested she should heed that warning.

But Lucy Blackstone had never been one to back down when the integrity of historical records was at stake. Clara Beth had died trying to bring a long-hidden truth to light. The least Lucy could do was finish what her friend had started.

Besides, she'd always believed that knowledge was the ultimate power. And if she was right about where Clara Beth had hidden her backup evidence, knowledge was exactly what she was about to gain.

8

The library after hours had always been one of Lucy's favorite places in Brentwood Falls. The hushed stillness, the comforting smell of books, the soft creaking of the old building settling—all combined to create a peaceful sanctuary that usually calmed her racing thoughts. Tonight, however, every shadow seemed menacing, every unfamiliar sound a potential threat.

True to her word, Lucy had called Sheriff Pritchard about the threatening note, though she'd been deliberately vague about her plans to search the library. Hank had been predictably concerned, insisting on driving past the library periodically throughout the evening.

"I'm not taking any chances with another murder in my town," he'd declared firmly. "Especially not when the potential victim is being so stubbornly independent."

Lucy had chosen not to be offended by his characterization.

Now, as the grandfather clock in the reference section chimed nine, Lucy made her way through the darkened stacks toward the philosophy section. She moved quietly despite being alone, her flashlight beam sweeping methodically across shelf markers until she reached the 187 classification.

The section was small—ethics wasn't a particularly popular subject in Brentwood Falls—which made her task both easier and more nerve-wracking. If Clara Beth had hidden something here, Lucy should find it relatively quickly. If not, she'd have wasted precious time on a theory that might be completely wrong.

"Think like Clara Beth," she murmured to herself, examining the shelf. "Where would you hide something important?"

Lucy began methodically checking each volume, pulling books partway out to look behind them, flipping through pages for inserted notes, examining dust jackets for hidden pockets. Nothing seemed out of place.

After twenty minutes of increasingly frustrated searching, Lucy sat on a nearby step stool, reconsidering her theory. Maybe she'd misinterpreted Clara Beth's annotation about "page 187." Maybe it had nothing to do with the Dewey Decimal System at all.

As she pondered, Lucy's gaze drifted upward to the top shelf, where several oversize philosophy reference books stood. One volume in particular caught her attention—"Ethical Considerations in Historical Documentation"—a book Lucy knew hadn't circulated in years. In fact, she couldn't remember the last time anyone had even taken it down for reference.

Perfect hiding place.

Lucy positioned the library ladder and climbed up to reach the oversized volume. As she pulled it from the shelf, she immediately knew something was different. The book felt heavier than it should, and something shifted inside when she moved it.

Her heart racing, Lucy carefully carried the book to a nearby table and opened it. The pages had been expertly hollowed out, creating a hidden compartment within the book's cover. Inside lay a sealed manila envelope with "READ ME" written across the front in Clara Beth's distinctive handwriting.

"Clever, Clara Beth," Lucy whispered with a mixture of admiration and sadness.

With trembling fingers, Lucy opened the envelope and spread its contents across the table. Inside was a handwritten letter from Clara Beth, several photocopied pages, and what appeared to be photographs of handwritten diary entries.

Lucy began with Clara Beth's letter:

Dear Lucy,

If you're reading this, something has prevented me from presenting my findings at the book fair as planned. I've left this package where I know your librarian's instincts will eventually lead you.

What I've discovered will shock Brentwood Falls to its core. The Barlow family fortune—and by extension, our town's primary financial institution—was built on fraud, theft, and murder.

The enclosed photocopies are from Jeremiah Wells' personal journal, which I acquired at the Millfield estate sale. His marginal notes provide eyewitness testimony to what really happened in September 1885. In short: Emmett Barlow murdered James Fairchild to gain control of valuable creek-front property, then systematically altered town records to hide his crime.

Even more disturbing is the methodical way historical documentation was modified after the fact. Someone (likely Emmett's son) went through "Foundation and Growth" and altered footnotes that referenced the dispute. However, they missed the clever safeguard Jeremiah Wells had incorporated—a coded message visible when reading the first letter of each sentence in certain footnotes.

I confronted Frank Barlow with this evidence last week, offering him the opportunity to acknowledge his family's historical wrongdoing before I published my findings. His reaction was concerning—anger followed by barely veiled threats about "protecting family legacy at all costs."

I don't take these threats lightly, which is why I've created this backup documentation. The original journal is secured elsewhere, with instructions for its delivery to the sheriff if anything happens to me.

Trust your instincts, Lucy. The truth is in the footnotes.

Yours in historical accuracy,

Clara Beth Jennings

Lucy sat back, her mind racing. Clara Beth had confronted Frank Barlow directly—and apparently, his response had worried her enough to create this hidden evidence cache.

Next, Lucy examined the photocopied journal pages. They showed entries from September 1885, written in a cramped but legible hand. The main text described town business and weather observations, but the margins told a different story—Jeremiah Wells had used the margins to record his private thoughts, including suspicions about James Fairchild's sudden death:

Sept. 23, 1885 (margin): Fairchild found dead this morning. Convenient timing, with the boundary dispute to be settled next week. Sheriff claims heart failure, but Elizabeth insists James was in perfect health. More troubling, the survey maps J.F. mentioned finding are nowhere to be located. E.B. visited my office immediately after the news broke, pressing for swift resolution in his favor now that Fairchild "cannot contest." Something feels very wrong about this entire matter.

Sept. 25, 1885 (margin): Elizabeth brought concerning evidence today—J.F.'s teacup from the night of his death, containing unusual residue. Dr. Monroe dismisses her fears as "grieving widow's imagination," but I'm not so certain. E.B. was known to study botanical properties extensively. Council records should reflect my objection to proceeding with boundary settlement so hastily.

Sept. 29, 1885 (margin): Outrageous development at council meeting. Pages containing Elizabeth's testimony mysteriously "lost" from record book. When I objected, three council members (all with financial interests connected to E.B.) voted to proceed with boundary settlement anyway. The creek property now transfers to Barlow holdings, despite legitimate evidence suggesting the boundary line favored Fairchild claim. I record here what will be excised from official minutes: This proceeding is a travesty of justice, conducted in the shadow of what I believe to be murder.

The final photocopied page contained the most damning marginal note:

Oct. 3, 1885 (margin): What I dare not state publicly, I record here for posterity. E.B. visited Fairchild's home the evening before his death. They were seen arguing by multiple witnesses. The constable found footprints matching E.B.'s distinctive boots beneath J.F.'s study window. Most damningly, the distinctive symptoms described by Elizabeth suggest poisoning by water hemlock, which grows in abundance on E.B.'s property. Yet the council has been silenced, records altered, and justice subverted by financial influence. May future generations find this truth and know the foundation upon which the Barlow fortune was truly built: blood and deceit.

Lucy's hands trembled as she set down the photocopies. Jeremiah Wells had documented what he believed to be a murder and subsequent cover-up, preserving the truth in his private journal when it had been systematically erased from public records.

The final items in Clara Beth's packet were photographs of several footnotes from "Foundation and Growth," with annotations showing how the first letters formed a coded message when read in sequence:

M-U-R-D-E-R-E-D F-A-I-R-C-H-I-L-D F-O-R C-R-E-E-K A-C-C-E-S-S E-M-M-E-T-T B-A-R-L-O-W G-U-I-L-T-Y W-E-L-L-S K-N-E-W T-R-U-T-H

At the bottom of this page was Clara Beth's final note:

The original journal is hidden where the story begins—at the source of the dispute itself. Look for the old willow at the creek bend on the original boundary line. JW was clever enough to ensure the truth couldn't be completely erased.

Lucy carefully gathered the documents, her mind processing the implications. Clara Beth had discovered not just historical footnotes but evidence of a murder and systematic alteration of public records—a cover-up that had allowed the Barlow family to build their fortune on stolen land.

And Frank Barlow had killed to protect that secret.

Lucy checked her watch—9:45 PM. Sheriff Pritchard would be making another drive-by soon. This time, she'd flag him down and show him what she'd found.

As she made her way to the front of the library, Lucy suddenly froze. Through the glass doors, she could see a dark figure approaching across the parking lot—too tall to be Hank, too purposeful to be a casual passerby.

Lucy ducked behind the circulation desk, heart pounding. She hadn't turned on the main lights, preferring to work with just her flashlight, which meant the intruder likely couldn't see her inside the darkened building.

From her hiding place, she watched as Frank Barlow—for she could now clearly see his face in the security lights—approached the library entrance. He tested the door handle, found it locked, then moved to peer through the glass, cupping his hands around his eyes to block the reflection.

Lucy held her breath, pressing herself against the circulation desk. She couldn't tell if he'd spotted her, but after a long, tense moment, Frank stepped back from the door. Instead of leaving, however, he moved around the side of the building, disappearing from view.

The side entrance. Though normally kept locked, it had been having issues with the latch recently. If Frank knew about this from his position on the library board...

Lucy didn't wait to find out. She immediately pulled out her cell phone and dialed 911.

"Emergency Services, what's your situation?"

"This is Lucy Blackstone at the Brentwood Falls Library," she whispered urgently. "Someone is trying to break in while I'm inside. I need Sheriff Pritchard immediately."

"Stay on the line, Ms. Blackstone. I'm dispatching officers now."

Lucy could hear the dispatcher radioing for assistance, but her attention was focused on the faint sounds coming from the side of the building. A soft scraping, followed by the distinctive click of the problematic door latch giving way.

He was inside.

Moving as quietly as possible, Lucy crawled from behind the circulation desk toward the staff area, where a secondary exit led to the back parking lot. The envelope with Clara Beth's evidence was clutched tightly in her hand.

"Lucy?" The dispatcher's voice suddenly seemed too loud in the silent library. "Are you still there?"

Lucy quickly muted the phone but kept the line open. As she reached the staff door, she heard footsteps in the main library area. Frank was methodically searching, moving from section to section.

The staff exit was only ten feet away. If she could reach it without being detected...

"I know you're in here, Lucy."

Frank's voice echoed through the darkened library, eerily calm and controlled.

"I saw your car in the back lot. Let's not make this more difficult than it needs to be."

Lucy froze, calculating her options. The exit was so close, but any movement might give away her position.

"This doesn't have to end badly," Frank continued, his footsteps drawing nearer. "Whatever you think you've found, we can discuss it rationally. Like Clara Beth should have done."

The casual reference to Clara Beth's murder sent a chill down Lucy's spine. Frank Barlow was clearly beyond caring about hiding his guilt.

"Did Clara Beth show you her 'evidence'?" Frank's voice dripped with disdain. "Historical footnotes and cryptic codes? No court would take that seriously. But she wouldn't listen to reason. She was determined to destroy my family's legacy over ancient history."

He was in the reference section now, just one row of shelves away from where Lucy crouched.

"A hundred and forty years, Lucy. That's how long the Barlows have been Brentwood Falls' financial backbone. Do you think anyone really cares how it started? Do you think they want to know their mortgages, business loans, college funds—all built on what some might call questionable foundations?"

Lucy could see his shadow now, stretching across the floor as he moved methodically through the stacks.

"The town needs the bank. The bank needs the Barlow reputation. It's that simple. Clara Beth couldn't understand that some truths serve no purpose except destruction."

In the distance, Lucy heard the blessed sound of sirens approaching. Frank heard them too—his shadow stiffened, then moved more quickly.

"Where are you, Lucy?" His voice had lost its forced calm, edged now with desperation. "What have you found?"

The staff door was still her best option. As Frank moved toward the philosophy section, Lucy seized her chance. She darted for the exit, pushing through the door into the cool night air just as she heard Frank shout behind her.

Sheriff Pritchard's patrol car was screeching into the parking lot, lights flashing. Lucy ran toward it as Hank leapt out, hand on his holstered weapon.

"Lucy! What's happening?"

"Frank Barlow is inside," she gasped. "He broke in through the side entrance. He's destroyed evidence of a historical murder to protect his family's reputation, and he killed Clara Beth when she discovered the truth."

As if on cue, the staff door burst open again, and Frank emerged, stopping short at the sight of Sheriff Pritchard.

"Sheriff," he said, visibly struggling to compose himself. "There's a perfectly reasonable explanation for this."

"I'm sure there is," Hank replied dryly, his hand not moving from his weapon. "You can share it downtown. Frank Barlow, you're under arrest for breaking and entering, to start with."

"This is ridiculous," Frank protested as Hank approached with handcuffs. "I'm on the library board. I was conducting an after-hours inspection."

"By breaking in through the side door?" Hank asked skeptically. "After sending threatening notes to the head librarian?"

While Hank recited Frank's rights, Deputy Tom Wentworth arrived in a second patrol car. Lucy explained what had happened, showing him Clara Beth's hidden evidence packet.

"We need to search his home immediately," she urged. "The missing library book is in a locked display case in his study. And according to Clara Beth's notes, the original Wells journal is hidden by the creek on his property—at the old boundary line."

"One step at a time," Tom cautioned, though he was already examining the photocopied journal entries with professional interest. "We'll need a search warrant."

"Based on what we have here, plus his break-in tonight, I don't think that will be a problem," Lucy replied.

The next morning dawned bright and clear, a stark contrast to the grim business at hand. Armed with a search warrant, Sheriff Pritchard and Deputy Wentworth had headed to the Barlow estate at first light. Lucy, despite Hank's strenuous objections, had insisted on accompanying them.

"I know exactly what we're looking for and where to find it," she'd argued. "Besides, as the head librarian, I need to officially identify the missing book."

Hank had relented with poor grace, but Lucy suspected he understood her need for closure.

Margaret Barlow had been predictably shocked when officers arrived with a search warrant, but her aristocratic composure quickly reasserted itself. She watched with icy dignity as they entered her husband's study.

"The display case," Lucy directed, pointing to the locked glass cabinet she'd noticed during her previous visit.

Inside, exactly where she remembered seeing it, was "Foundation and Growth: A Historical Account of Brentwood Falls." When Sheriff Pritchard removed it, Lucy immediately identified the library markings on the spine.

"That's our missing copy," she confirmed. "The one Clara Beth was researching before her death."

But the truly damning evidence came from the creek. Following Clara Beth's cryptic note about "where the story begins," they searched along the creek bend on what maps showed as the original disputed boundary line. There, beneath an ancient willow tree, they found a waterproof container buried among the roots.

Inside was Jeremiah Wells' personal journal—the missing piece that completed Clara Beth's historical puzzle.

"She knew Frank might find her research at home or the Historical Society," Lucy explained as they carefully bagged the journal as evidence. "So she hid the most important piece where only someone following her specific clues would look."

Back at the sheriff's office, the evidence against Frank Barlow mounted. Forensic examination of the threatening note sent to Lucy revealed fingerprints matching Frank's. A search of his personal computer uncovered surveillance photos of Clara Beth in the weeks leading up to her death, suggesting premeditation.

Most damning of all, they found a draft email to Frank's attorney, dated the day after Clara Beth's murder:

Need to discuss potential historical liability issue. Local historian preparing to publish damaging claims about original land acquisition. Could affect bank's standing if ownership of headquarters property is legally challenged. Situation currently contained but requires legal strategy for potential fallout.

"'Situation currently contained,'" Hank read grimly. "Written hours after Clara Beth was murdered."

By afternoon, Frank Barlow had been formally charged with first-degree murder in Clara Beth's death, attempted murder regarding Lucy, breaking and entering, evidence tampering, and a host of lesser charges.

"We're still building the case," Hank explained to Lucy as they sat in his office, the collected evidence spread before them. "But between the historical documentation Clara Beth found, the physical evidence from the crime scene, and Frank's actions since the murder, we have a solid case."

"What about the historical land fraud?" Lucy asked. "And the implications for the bank?"

Hank sighed heavily. "That's more complicated. The statute of limitations has long expired on anything Emmett Barlow did in 1885. As for the current bank property... well, after 140 years of continuous possession, challenging ownership becomes legally murky."

"So the Barlow family gets to keep land acquired through murder?" Lucy couldn't keep the indignation from her voice.

"The courts will decide that," Hank replied diplomatically. "What matters for now is that Clara Beth's killer will face justice, and the historical record she fought to protect will be preserved."

Lucy nodded, though the resolution felt incomplete. "There's one more thing I don't understand. Clara Beth's appointment book mentioned presenting her findings to Frank 'before publication.' What publication was she planning?"

"Ah, I was going to show you this," Hank said, pulling a folder from his desk. "We found it when searching her home computer. Clara Beth had completed a manuscript titled 'Foundations of Fraud: How Brentwood Falls' History Was Rewritten.' She had already submitted it to a university press specializing in regional history."

He slid the manuscript proposal across the desk. "According to their response email, they were enthusiastic about publishing it. The contract was set to be signed the week after the book fair."

Lucy thumbed through the proposal, recognizing Clara Beth's meticulous research and passionate advocacy for historical truth. The final lines of the introduction summed up her purpose perfectly:

"Historical accuracy isn't merely academic—it's essential to understanding how power structures in our communities were formed and maintained. When we allow historical revision to go unchallenged, we become complicit in perpetuating injustice. This book aims to correct a 140-year-old falsehood and restore integrity to Brentwood Falls' historical record, whatever uncomfortable truths that may reveal."

"She really was extraordinary," Lucy said softly, closing the folder. "She died defending historical truth."

"And you nearly followed in her footsteps," Hank pointed out severely. "Though I'm grateful you didn't."

As Lucy left the sheriff's office, she felt a complex mixture of emotions—satisfaction that Clara Beth's killer would face justice, pride in her friend's principled stand for historical accuracy, and relief that the truth had finally emerged from the footnotes where it had been hidden for generations.

The library would receive back its missing book. The Wells journal would likely end up in a proper historical archive. And most importantly, the story Clara Beth had died trying to tell would finally be heard.

The truth, as it always did in Lucy's experience, had found its way out of the margins and into the light.

9

Lucy had always believed in the power of libraries as community gathering spaces, but she'd never imagined her beloved Brentwood Falls Library would become the stage for unmasking a murderer. Yet here she was, rearranging the reading room chairs into rows facing the small podium normally reserved for visiting authors and children's story hour.

"Are you absolutely certain about this?" Hazel asked as she helped Lucy set up a refreshment table at the back of the room. "Publicly accusing a prominent citizen of murder seems more like something from one of your mystery novels than real life."

"It's not an accusation," Lucy clarified, adjusting the microphone stand. "It's a presentation of historical findings. With Sheriff Pritchard's approval, I might add."

This wasn't entirely accurate. What Hank had actually said was, "I can't stop you from hosting a library event, but if this goes sideways, I'm not responsible for the fallout." Still, he had agreed to attend, which was all that mattered for Lucy's plan.

"And if Frank Barlow doesn't take the bait?" Hazel persisted.

Lucy arranged a stack of photocopied handouts on the podium. "According to Tilly's sources, he's already planning to attend—ostensibly to 'protect the Barlow family reputation from baseless historical speculation.'"

"Of course Tilly has sources," Hazel muttered. "What journalist worth her salt wouldn't have spies tracking a potential murderer?"

The flyers Lucy had distributed around town had been deliberately provocative: "Historical Cover-Up Revealed: The Truth Behind Brentwood Falls' Founding Families." She'd scheduled the event for 7 PM, ensuring maximum attendance from both working townspeople and retirees.

By 6:45, the reading room was filling with curious citizens. Lucy recognized familiar faces—Mrs. Fincher in her usual front-row seat, Maggie Sue Robbins with several fellow teachers, Walter Phillips from the Historical Society, and Jed Forrester from The Brentwood Antiquarian. Even Mayor Levi Parson had arrived, looking uncomfortable but determined to represent the town's interests.

At precisely 7 PM, Lucy approached the podium, her heart racing despite her outward composure. Sheriff Pritchard and Deputy Wentworth had positioned themselves discreetly near the back doors, and Tilly sat poised with her reporter's notebook in the second row.

"Good evening, everyone," Lucy began, her librarian's voice carrying clearly through the room. "Thank you for joining us for this important historical presentation. As many of you know, our town recently suffered a tragic loss with the death of Clara Beth Jennings at our annual book fair."

A murmur of acknowledgment rippled through the audience.

"Clara Beth was more than our town historian—she was a dedicated guardian of historical truth. In the weeks before her death, she made a remarkable discovery about Brentwood Falls' early history, specifically regarding the northwestern boundary settlement of 1885."

Lucy glanced toward the entrance just as Frank Barlow slipped in, taking a position against the back wall rather than sitting. His face was composed, but she could see tension in the set of his shoulders.

Perfect timing.

"Through meticulous research, Clara Beth uncovered evidence that the historical record regarding the boundary dispute between the Fairchild and Barlow families had been deliberately altered," Lucy continued. "These alterations appear in town council minutes, property records, and even published historical accounts."

She displayed the first slide showing the photocopy of the town council minutes with missing pages. "As you can see, crucial pages were physically removed from official records—pages that would have documented the disputed resolution process."

The audience leaned forward, intrigued by this concrete evidence of tampering.

"More significantly," Lucy continued, "Clara Beth discovered that 'Foundation and Growth: A Historical Account of Brentwood Falls'—our library's primary historical reference on the town's early years—contained footnotes that had been altered to change the historical narrative."

From his position near the wall, Frank Barlow shifted slightly, his right hand unconsciously moving to adjust his tie.

"But Clara Beth made an even more remarkable discovery," Lucy said, her voice dropping slightly so that the audience would lean in further. "The original author of these footnotes, understanding that future attempts might be made to alter the record, embedded a coded message—a message that survived despite later modifications."

She displayed the slide showing the first-letter code that spelled out "MURDERED FAIRCHILD FOR CREEK ACCESS EMMETT BARLOW GUILTY."

A collective gasp rose from the audience, followed by the buzz of whispered conversations.

"This alone would be a significant historical finding," Lucy acknowledged, "but Clara Beth sought additional confirmation. She managed to locate Jeremiah Wells' personal journal—a primary source that had been missing from public records for generations."

At the mention of the journal, Frank took a half-step forward, his casual observer stance giving way to visible tension.

"Wells' journal contains explicit marginal notes documenting his suspicions that James Fairchild's death was not from natural causes, but rather a deliberate poisoning connected to the land dispute. He further documents how evidence was suppressed, witness testimony removed from records, and the boundary decision pushed through despite legitimate objections."

Mayor Parson stood up. "Ms. Blackstone, these are extremely serious allegations about one of our founding families. Do you have actual evidence beyond coded messages and marginal notes?"

"A fair question, Mayor," Lucy nodded respectfully. "Historical research often requires piecing together fragments when systematic efforts have been made to erase certain narratives. However, in this case, we have multiple corroborating sources."

She proceeded to display the letter from Elizabeth Fairchild to her sister, followed by the analysis of altered sheriff reports and property records showing the sudden transfer of valuable creek-front land.

"Most significantly," Lucy continued, "the land acquired through this questionable process—land that included valuable water rights that subsequently generated substantial wealth for the Barlow family—has never left Barlow family hands. It remains to this day the site of both the Barlow estate and the First Brentwood Bank headquarters."

Frank Barlow finally stepped forward from his position against the wall. "This is nothing but historical speculation and innuendo," he declared, his banker's voice carrying authority despite his obvious agitation. "Whatever Clara Beth Jennings thought she discovered, she was connecting unrelated coincidences into a conspiracy theory."

Lucy had been waiting for this interruption. "Mr. Barlow, thank you for joining us. As a representative of one of our founding families, your perspective is valuable. Would you care to explain why pages were physically removed from town council records specifically regarding the boundary dispute involving your ancestor?"

Frank's face flushed slightly. "Historical records from that period are notoriously incomplete. Documents deteriorate, get damaged by water or fire, are misplaced during reorganizations. To suggest deliberate tampering based on missing pages from 140 years ago is absurd."

"And the altered footnotes in our library's copy of 'Foundation and Growth'?" Lucy pressed. "The same book that mysteriously disappeared after Clara Beth began her research?"

"I have no knowledge of any missing library book," Frank replied stiffly. "Though I would point out that books frequently go missing from public libraries."

Lucy nodded thoughtfully. "Indeed they do. Which is why librarians are so careful about maintaining accurate records." She turned to her next slide, which showed the circulation record for "Foundation and Growth," highlighting Clara Beth's and Tilly's check-outs. "As you can see, the book was properly returned to the library but subsequently vanished from our shelves."

Frank's composure slipped for just a moment. "Perhaps someone else borrowed it without checking it out. It hardly constitutes evidence of... whatever it is you're implying."

"I'm not implying anything, Mr. Barlow," Lucy replied calmly. "I'm presenting historical findings that Clara Beth Jennings documented before her death. Findings she was planning to publish in a book that would have raised serious questions about the legitimacy of certain property claims in Brentwood Falls."

This was the moment to spring the trap.

"In fact," Lucy continued, "Clara Beth had already submitted her manuscript to a university press. They were enthusiastic about publishing her research."

Frank's face had gone from flushed to pale. "This is getting dangerously close to libel, Ms. Blackstone. Historical speculation is one thing, but suggesting that my family's property was acquired through... illicit means... is quite another."

"I understand your concern," Lucy said sympathetically. "Clara Beth anticipated resistance to her findings. That's why she was so meticulous about documentation. She even created backup copies of her evidence."

Lucy glanced meaningfully toward Sheriff Pritchard, who had moved slightly closer to the front of the room.

"In fact," she continued, "Clara Beth gave me something for safekeeping—something she feared might be destroyed if her research became too threatening to certain interests."

This was a bluff—Clara Beth had done no such thing—but Lucy watched Frank's reaction carefully.

"What exactly are you claiming to have?" he demanded, his businessman's composure cracking further.

"A complete photographic record of Jeremiah Wells' journal," Lucy replied smoothly, "Including his detailed marginal notes about what he believed to be James Fairchild's murder and the subsequent cover-up orchestrated by Emmett Barlow."

Frank took another step forward. "That's impossible. The journal was—" He stopped abruptly, realizing his mistake.

"Was what, Mr. Barlow?" Lucy prompted gently. "How would you know anything about a journal that was supposedly lost to history until Clara Beth discovered it recently?"

The room had gone completely silent, every eye fixed on Frank Barlow.

"I... she mentioned it during our meeting at the café," he improvised. "Clara Beth was always talking about her historical discoveries."

"Interesting," Lucy nodded. "Because according to her appointment book, when you met with her at The Daily Grind, she was presenting her findings to you before publication—giving you the opportunity to address the historical record voluntarily." She paused. "I wonder why she felt the need to do that."

Frank's tie adjustment had become almost compulsive. "This is ridiculous. I'm not going to stand here and be subjected to thinly veiled accusations based on historical footnotes and conspiracy theories."

"No one is accusing you of anything, Mr. Barlow," Lucy said, her voice deliberately gentle. "We're simply exploring the historical research that Clara Beth was conducting before her tragic death at the book fair."

"A death that remains unsolved," Frank pointed out, attempting to regain control of the narrative. "Perhaps instead of historical speculation, the sheriff's department should be focusing on finding whoever killed her."

"Oh, but they have been," Lucy replied. "In fact, they've been quite thorough in examining all the evidence—including security camera footage from the town square on the day of the book fair."

This was another bluff. There were no cameras with a clear view of Clara Beth's booth, but Frank Barlow couldn't know that for certain.

The effect was immediate. Frank's face drained of color. "What footage?"

"The library installed new security cameras last month," Lucy improvised. "The exterior ones have excellent coverage of the grounds where the book fair was held."

Frank's eyes darted to Sheriff Pritchard, who maintained an impassive professional expression.

"But more interesting than any footage," Lucy continued relentlessly, "is what Clara Beth discovered in Wells' journal about the original murder. According to her notes, Emmett Barlow used a plant-based poison commonly found on his property—water hemlock. The symptoms described by Elizabeth Fairchild in her letters match perfectly."

Frank's composure was visibly crumbling. "This is all speculation and coincidence. You have no proof of anything."

"Actually," Lucy said, carefully maintaining her librarian's calm, "we have quite a bit of proof. Clara Beth was extremely thorough in her documentation." She gestured to the stack of handouts on the podium. "These packets contain copies of her research, including her analysis of the coded footnotes that first led her to suspect historical tampering."

"Those footnotes were never meant to be taken literally," Frank insisted, his voice rising. "They're just an artifact of the writing style of the period!"

Lucy looked at him curiously. "How would you know that, Mr. Barlow? The book has been missing from the library for weeks. Have you had an opportunity to examine it recently?"

The trap was closing.

Frank seemed to realize his mistake. "I... I'm simply referring to what you've shown in your presentation."

"But I haven't displayed the actual footnote text," Lucy pointed out, "only Clara Beth's analysis of the hidden code. The original footnotes would only be familiar to someone who had recently examined the book itself."

The room had gone completely still, the collective realization spreading silently through the audience. Frank Barlow was sweating now, his banker's composure utterly abandoned.

"This is absurd," he declared, though his voice had lost its authoritative tone. "I came here to protect my family's reputation from baseless historical speculation, not to be ambushed with accusations and tricks."

"No tricks, Mr. Barlow," Lucy assured him. "Just historical documentation and logical questions. Such as why someone would send me a threatening note after I began looking into Clara Beth's research."

She pulled out the plastic bag containing the note: "DROP IT, OR YOU'LL BE NEXT."

"Or why someone would break into the library after hours when I was researching the same historical footnotes that had interested Clara Beth."

Frank's eyes darted toward the exit, but Sheriff Pritchard had moved to block the doorway.

"Or most curiously," Lucy continued, delivering the final blow, "why 'Foundation and Growth: A Historical Account of Brentwood Falls' would turn up in a locked display case in your private study when Sheriff Pritchard executed a search warrant yesterday afternoon."

This was no bluff. While Lucy's dramatic town meeting had been in preparation, Hank had quietly obtained a warrant based on the evidence they'd already gathered. The missing library book had indeed been found exactly where Lucy had seen it during her visit to the Barlow estate.

Frank Barlow stared at her, fight-or-flight instinct visibly warring across his features. "You were in my study? You had no right⁠—"

"Actually, she had an invitation," Sheriff Pritchard said, stepping forward. "According to her statement, you welcomed her into your home to discuss the library fundraiser. The book was in plain sight in your display case."

"This is... this is nothing but a witch hunt," Frank declared, desperation creeping into his voice. "So what if I have a copy of that book? It's a historical volume about Brentwood Falls. Many families have copies."

"With the Brentwood Falls Public Library stamp on the spine and circulation card in the back?" Hank asked mildly.

The audience erupted in whispers. Frank's gaze darted around the room like a cornered animal's. "I... I found it. Someone had clearly stolen it from the library and abandoned it. I was planning to return it."

"After removing the pages containing the coded footnotes?" Lucy asked quietly.

Frank froze. "What?"

"The book recovered from your study is missing several key pages," Sheriff Pritchard explained. "Specifically, the pages containing the footnotes Clara Beth had identified as containing coded messages."

"I had nothing to do with that," Frank insisted. "The book must have been damaged when I found it."

"And Wells' journal?" Lucy pressed. "The one Clara Beth was so excited about displaying at the book fair? The one that mysteriously disappeared after her murder?"

"I know nothing about any journal!" Frank's voice had risen to near-shouting.

Lucy nodded thoughtfully. "Interesting. Because according to the groundskeeper at your estate, you instructed him to cut down an old willow tree by the creek bend last week. The same tree that once marked the disputed boundary line between the Fairchild and Barlow properties."

This was another calculated bluff, but Frank's reaction told her everything. His face went from pale to ashen.

"How did you... who told you..."

"Clara Beth left clues," Lucy replied simply. "She knew where to look for historical truth—and so did I."

Frank Barlow's composure finally shattered completely. "She was going to destroy everything! Generations of work, the bank's reputation, my family's standing—all over some ancient land dispute that no one cares about anymore!"

The audience fell silent, shocked by the outburst.

"She wouldn't listen to reason," Frank continued, seemingly unaware that he was confessing in front of dozens of witnesses. "I explained that exposing this so-called 'historical fraud' would only harm the town—the bank is Brentwood Falls' financial foundation! But she was obsessed with 'historical accuracy' regardless of the consequences."

Sheriff Pritchard stepped forward, his hand moving to the handcuffs on his belt. "Frank Barlow, I think we need to continue this conversation down at the station."

"This proves nothing," Frank insisted, though his voice had lost its conviction. "Historical disputes, missing books—none of this connects to Clara Beth's death."

"Perhaps not directly," Sheriff Pritchard acknowledged. "But tampering with library materials, breaking and entering, and sending threatening messages are all prosecutable offenses. And they establish a pattern that gives us grounds for a more thorough investigation into Clara Beth's murder."

As Hank began to read Frank his rights, the banker seemed to deflate before their eyes, the weight of his actions finally crushing his carefully maintained façade.

"She gave me a chance to address it privately," he said, almost to himself. "If she'd just been reasonable... if she'd understood what was at stake..."

Deputy Wentworth led Frank toward the exit, the shocked audience parting to let them through. As they reached the door, Frank turned back to look at Lucy, his expression a complex mixture of anger, defeat, and something like grudging respect.

"You're just like her," he said. "Too stubborn to leave the past buried."

Then he was gone, escorted to the waiting patrol car outside.

The reading room erupted in excited conversations as the implications of what they'd witnessed sank in. Tilly was already furiously taking notes for what would undoubtedly be the Gazette's biggest story in years. Mayor Parson looked shell-shocked, likely already calculating the political fallout from a prominent citizen's public meltdown.

Sheriff Pritchard returned to Lucy's side after Frank had been placed in the patrol car. "That," he said dryly, "was not exactly how we discussed this going."

"But it worked," Lucy pointed out. "He practically confessed in front of the entire town."

"To historical document tampering and threatening you," Hank corrected. "The murder investigation still requires proper evidence and procedure."

"Which you'll have once you search for the journal at the creek," Lucy countered.

Hank sighed. "Lucy, there might not be any journal there. That was quite a bluff you played."

"It wasn't entirely a bluff," Lucy replied. "Clara Beth's notes mentioned that the original journal was hidden 'where the story begins—at the source of the dispute itself.' The creek boundary was where everything started."

"We'll search the area tomorrow," Hank promised. "But even without the journal, Frank Barlow incriminated himself enough tonight to justify holding him while we build the murder case."

As the crowd gradually dispersed, still buzzing with excitement over the dramatic revelations, Hazel approached with two cups of tea.

"I figured you could use this," she said, handing one to Lucy. "That was either the most brilliant or the most reckless thing I've ever seen."

"Maybe a bit of both," Lucy admitted, her hands slightly unsteady as the adrenaline began to fade. "But Clara Beth deserved to have the truth come out—both about her murder and about the historical cover-up she discovered."

"I'd say mission accomplished," Hazel nodded toward where Tilly was interviewing Walter Phillips about the historical implications of the evening's revelations. "The truth is definitely out now."

As Lucy sipped her tea, she gazed around the reading room—her library, her domain of books and knowledge. Tonight it had served its highest purpose: revealing truth that had been deliberately hidden and bringing justice to light.

Clara Beth would have approved.

10

Autumn had fully settled over Brentwood Falls by the time Frank Barlow's case went to trial. The maple trees lining Main Street had transformed into brilliant displays of crimson and gold, and a crisp breeze carried the scent of woodsmoke and apple cider through town. Lucy found the seasonal transformation fitting—a time of change and renewal after the revelations that had shaken their community to its core.

She sat in her office at the library, reviewing the final proofs for Clara Beth's book. The university press had been remarkably accommodating, agreeing to publish "Foundations of Fraud: How Brentwood Falls' History Was Rewritten" posthumously. They'd even asked Lucy to write the foreword, an honor that had left her both humbled and determined to do justice to her friend's meticulous research.

A soft knock interrupted her concentration.

"Come in," Lucy called, looking up to see Tilly Harper in the doorway, clutching her ever-present messenger bag and wearing an expression of barely contained excitement.

"It's official," Tilly announced without preamble. "Frank Barlow has accepted a plea deal. Twenty-five years for second-degree murder, plus additional time for evidence tampering, breaking and entering, and threatening a witness—that's you."

Lucy set down her red editing pencil. "No chance of parole?"

"Not for at least fifteen years," Tilly confirmed, dropping into the chair across from Lucy's desk. "According to my source in the DA's office, Frank finally cracked when they recovered Jeremiah Wells' journal from the creek bank."

The journal had been found exactly where Lucy had suspected—buried in a waterproof container beneath the old willow tree that had once marked the disputed boundary line. Though Frank had instructed his groundskeeper to remove the tree, the man had only partially completed the job before being called away for a family emergency, leaving the roots and the hidden evidence intact.

"The marginal notes matched the photocopies Clara Beth had preserved," Tilly continued. "Between that, the threatening note with his fingerprints, the security footage from the bank showing him leaving during the book fair, and his public meltdown at your town meeting... well, his attorneys advised him that a jury trial would likely end with a life sentence."

Lucy nodded, feeling not satisfaction but a somber sense of justice served. "Has he ever explained why he did it? Beyond protecting the family reputation?"

"According to my source, he was in serious financial trouble," Tilly replied. "The bank was facing a regulatory audit, and if questions about property ownership had surfaced at the same time..." She shrugged expressively. "Banking regulations are extremely strict about property titles. If the bank headquarters land title had been invalidated due to Clara Beth's research, it could have triggered a catastrophic audit failure."

"So it wasn't just historical pride," Lucy mused. "It was modern-day financial survival."

"Pride, money, power—the classic motives," Tilly agreed. "Speaking of which, I just finished my feature piece on the historical implications of Clara Beth's research. I was hoping you might look it over before we go to print."

Lucy accepted the offered manuscript pages. "I'd be honored."

As Tilly departed, promising to return later for Lucy's feedback, Hazel appeared with two steaming mugs of tea.

"I saw the journalistic whirlwind blow in," she said, setting one mug on Lucy's desk. "News about Frank Barlow?"

Lucy filled her in on the plea deal as they sipped their tea.

"Twenty-five years," Hazel shook her head. "Hard to believe someone we've known all our lives—the president of our only bank—turned out to be capable of murder."

"People will go to extraordinary lengths to protect what they value," Lucy observed. "For Frank, it was family legacy and financial stability. The irony is that by trying to preserve his family's reputation, he destroyed it completely."

"Speaking of reputations," Hazel said, "have you heard the latest about Mayor Parson? He's called a special town meeting for tonight."

Lucy raised an eyebrow. "Another one? The last town meeting was eventful enough to last us a decade."

"Rumor has it he's going to address his role in trying to suppress Clara Beth's research," Hazel replied. "Marge overheard him practicing his speech in the town hall bathroom—apparently he thought he was alone."

Lucy couldn't help but smile at the small-town grapevine's efficiency. "Let me guess—Marge's second cousin's wife works as the town hall receptionist?"

"Cleaning staff, actually," Hazel corrected with a grin. "Either way, sounds like the mayor is finally ready to come clean about whatever he knew."

The town hall was packed that evening. After the dramatic revelations at the library and Frank Barlow's subsequent arrest, the citizens of Brentwood Falls were understandably eager for any new developments. Lucy and Hazel found seats near the back, nodding to familiar faces as they settled in.

Mayor Levi Parson looked distinctly uncomfortable as he approached the podium, his usual confident stride replaced by the hesitant steps of a man heading to an unpleasant dental appointment.

"Thank you all for coming this evening," he began, his voice lacking its typical political resonance. "Recent events have raised questions about town leadership and transparency that I feel compelled to address."

The mayor paused, visibly gathering his courage.

"I want to state unequivocally that I had no knowledge of or involvement in Clara Beth Jennings' murder. However..." He took a deep breath. "I did attempt to discourage her from publishing her findings about the Barlow-Fairchild land dispute."

A murmur rippled through the audience.

"When Clara Beth approached me three months ago with her discoveries about altered historical records, I suggested that publishing such findings might damage our town's reputation and economic stability. I believed I was acting in Brentwood Falls' best interests." He gripped the podium edge tightly. "I was wrong."

Lucy exchanged surprised glances with Hazel. This level of candor from a politician was unexpected.

"The historical truth, however uncomfortable, belongs to all of us," the mayor continued. "By attempting to suppress that truth, I betrayed my responsibility as a public servant. For that, I sincerely apologize."

He straightened his shoulders, looking more like his usual self. "To ensure nothing like this happens again, I've drafted a town charter amendment establishing a Historical Truth and Reconciliation Committee, with members drawn from our Historical Society, library board, and general citizenry. This committee will have the authority and resources to investigate any aspects of our town's history without political interference."

As the mayor outlined the details of his proposed committee, Lucy found herself impressed despite her lingering skepticism. Creating an independent body to safeguard historical accuracy was exactly what Clara Beth would have wanted.

"Finally," Mayor Parson concluded, "I believe the most fitting tribute to Clara Beth Jennings' memory is the complete restoration of the historical record she fought to protect. To that end, I've authorized a special budget allocation for the preservation and digitization of all town records dating back to Brentwood Falls' founding. These digital records will be maintained jointly by the town clerk's office and the public library, ensuring both access and preservation for future generations."

The proposal received enthusiastic applause, with several Historical Society members appearing particularly moved by the announcement.

When the meeting adjourned, Lucy found herself approached by Walter Phillips from the Historical Society.

"Lucy," he greeted her warmly. "The mayor has asked me to chair the new committee, and I was hoping you might serve as our library liaison. Your role in bringing Clara Beth's research to light makes you the perfect candidate."

"I'd be honored," Lucy replied sincerely. "Clara Beth believed that historical truth was worth fighting for—even dying for. The least I can do is help ensure her work continues."

The following morning brought a small ceremony at the library. "Foundation and Growth: A Historical Account of Brentwood Falls" was being officially returned to the collection, though with a significant change in status. Rather than returning to general circulation, the volume—with its altered footnotes and coded messages—would be preserved in a special display case in the local history room, accompanied by an explanatory placard about its role in uncovering historical fraud and solving Clara Beth's murder.

A modest crowd had gathered for the occasion, including Mayor Parson, several library board members, and a handful of interested citizens. Sheriff Pritchard stood at the back, his presence both official and supportive.

Lucy carefully placed the book in its new protective case, treating the volume with the reverence it deserved despite—or perhaps because of—its complicated history.

"This book represents both the deliberate alteration of historical truth and the power of careful research to uncover such alterations," she explained to the assembled group. "The coded message Clara Beth discovered in these footnotes ultimately led to justice, not only for her murder but also for the historical record itself."

As she spoke, Lucy couldn't help but reflect on the remarkable journey that had begun with a cryptic message about footnotes holding the truth. Clara Beth's final words had indeed proven prophetic.

"Libraries have always served as guardians of knowledge," Lucy continued. "But today, we recognize that this guardianship sometimes requires active investigation rather than passive preservation. When Clara Beth discovered discrepancies in our historical records, she didn't simply note them—she pursued the truth with determination and courage."

Mayor Parson stepped forward after Lucy had finished, officially dedicating the display in Clara Beth's memory. He then presented Lucy with a surprise—a mayoral proclamation establishing an annual "Historical Accuracy Day" in Brentwood Falls, to be held each year on the anniversary of Clara Beth's birth.

"On this day," the proclamation read, "our community will commemorate Clara Beth Jennings' dedication to historical truth by highlighting aspects of local history that have been overlooked, misrepresented, or deliberately obscured."

Lucy accepted the framed proclamation with genuine appreciation. It was a fitting tribute to a woman who had given her life in pursuit of historical accuracy.

As the ceremony concluded and the attendees dispersed, Sheriff Pritchard approached Lucy with a smile that softened his usually serious demeanor.

"Not bad for a librarian who was just supposed to be organizing a book fair," he remarked.

"I suppose I got a bit sidetracked," Lucy admitted.

"That's one way of putting it," Hank chuckled. "Solving a murder, exposing a 140-year-old fraud, and bringing down the president of the town's only bank—all while cataloging the new mystery novels."

Lucy smiled at his teasing. "Just think of it as an extremely thorough reference inquiry."

"Well, your 'reference inquiry' has changed this town forever," Hank observed, his tone growing more serious. "For the better, I'd say."

Lucy followed his gaze around the library, taking in the patrons browsing shelves, the children gathered for story hour in the corner, and the new historical display that would ensure Clara Beth's discovery remained in public consciousness.

"Change isn't always comfortable," she acknowledged, "but truth has a way of demanding to be heard eventually."

"Speaking of truth," Hank said, "there's something you should know. When we were processing Frank Barlow's personal effects after his arrest, we found a journal—not Wells', but his own. It appears he'd been aware of his family's historical fraud for most of his adult life. His grandfather had passed down the truth as a sort of cautionary tale about protecting family interests at all costs."

Lucy's eyes widened. "So the historical cover-up was a family tradition?"

"Generation after generation," Hank confirmed. "Each Barlow patriarch apparently felt obligated to maintain the deception, seeing it as protecting their legacy rather than perpetuating a fraud."

"That's... genuinely sad," Lucy said after a moment's reflection. "Imagine living with that kind of secret hanging over you, constantly afraid that someone might discover the truth."

"Some secrets are too heavy to carry," Hank agreed. "Maybe in the end, Frank was almost relieved to have it exposed."

Two weeks later, the Brentwood Falls Book Fair finally had its proper conclusion. Initially canceled after Clara Beth's murder, the event had been rescheduled as both a celebration of literature and a memorial to the town historian whose love of truth had ultimately cost her life.

The library grounds were once again dotted with white tents and colorful displays, though with one notable addition—a special booth dedicated to Clara Beth's newly published book. Advance copies of "Foundations of Fraud" had arrived just in time for the fair, and a steady stream of curious citizens had been purchasing them throughout the day.

Lucy had volunteered to staff the booth during the afternoon, answering questions about Clara Beth's research and the historical implications of her discoveries. It was emotionally draining but deeply satisfying work.

"Quite a turnout," observed Deputy Tom Wentworth, appearing at her side during a brief lull in visitors. "Seems like everyone in town wants a copy."

"Nothing drives book sales like a murder and a century-old conspiracy," Lucy remarked with gentle irony.

"That, and a librarian willing to risk her life to solve both," Tom added, his admiration evident.

Lucy felt her cheeks warm slightly. "I was just following the footnotes, as Clara Beth would have said."

"Well, those footnotes led to some pretty significant changes around here." Tom gestured toward where Mayor Parson was chatting with members of the newly formed Historical Truth and Reconciliation Committee. "The mayor's approval ratings have actually improved since his confession. Turns out people appreciate honesty, even when it's belated."

"And the bank?" Lucy asked. The First Brentwood Bank had been in administrative limbo since Frank's arrest, causing considerable anxiety throughout the town.

"State regulators have approved a management transition," Tom reported. "Margaret Barlow has agreed to sell her shares, and a regional banking group is stepping in to ensure stability. They're even keeping all the current staff."

"That's a relief," Lucy said sincerely. Despite Frank's crimes, she hadn't wanted the entire town to suffer financial instability.

"The best part," Tom continued, "is that the Fairchild descendants have agreed to a settlement rather than pursuing invalidation of the original land claim. The bank will remain on its current site, but with a historical marker acknowledging the truth of how the property was acquired."

Lucy smiled. "Historical accuracy and practical compromise—Clara Beth would have approved of that solution."

As afternoon turned to evening, the book fair began its closing ceremony. Mayor Parson had asked Lucy to say a few words, a request she had accepted with both honor and trepidation. Public speaking had never been her forte—she preferred letting books do the talking.

Nevertheless, as she approached the small podium set up near the library's main entrance, Lucy felt a sense of rightness. This was where everything had begun, with Clara Beth's excitement about historical footnotes and her final cryptic message.

"Thank you all for making this rescheduled book fair such a success," Lucy began, surveying the gathered crowd. "Books have always been at the heart of our community, serving as vessels of knowledge, imagination, and—as we've recently discovered—truth that refuses to remain hidden."

A murmur of agreement rippled through the audience.

"Clara Beth Jennings understood something fundamental about written words: they persist. Even when documents are altered, pages removed, or histories rewritten, traces of truth remain for those patient and observant enough to find them."

Lucy gestured toward the library building behind her. "This is why libraries matter. Not just as repositories of books, but as guardians of the written record in all its forms. When Clara Beth discovered discrepancies in our historical documents, she turned to the library's resources to pursue that mystery. And when she realized the danger her discoveries might pose, she trusted the library to preserve her findings."

She paused, looking out at the familiar faces of her community—faces that now held a new awareness of their town's complicated past.

"Brentwood Falls has begun a new chapter," Lucy continued. "One that acknowledges our imperfect history while committing to greater transparency moving forward. The Historical Truth and Reconciliation Committee, the digitization of town records, the annual Historical Accuracy Day—these aren't just memorials to Clara Beth. They're promises to ourselves and future generations that we value truth, however uncomfortable it might sometimes be."

As Lucy concluded her remarks, the setting sun broke through the clouds, casting a golden light across the library grounds. It seemed to illuminate the white tents of the book fair with an almost ethereal glow, as if Clara Beth herself were offering a sign of approval.

Later, as Lucy helped dismantle displays and pack away unsold books, she found herself standing before the spot where Clara Beth's booth had been on that fateful day. The police tape was long gone, the physical evidence of tragedy erased, but Lucy could still picture her friend's excitement as she'd shown off Jeremiah Wells' journal and promised to reveal its secrets.

"She would be pleased," Hazel said softly, appearing at Lucy's side. "Not just about the book or the historical committee, but about you. You finished what she started."

"I just followed the clues she left," Lucy demurred.

"With remarkable stubbornness and at considerable personal risk," Hazel pointed out. "Don't downplay it, Lucy. What you did mattered."

Lucy smiled at her friend's insistence. "I suppose librarians and historians share a certain... persistence when it comes to uncovering information."

"Persistence is one word for it," Hazel laughed. "Mule-headed determination might be another."

As they walked back toward the library, Lucy paused to look up at the building that had been the center of her professional life for the past six years. Its solid brick walls and tall windows represented everything she valued—knowledge, community, and the enduring power of the written word.

Inside those walls, "Foundation and Growth" now rested in its display case, its altered footnotes and hidden code preserved for future generations to study. Nearby, copies of Clara Beth's posthumously published book offered the full, unvarnished truth about Brentwood Falls' founding families.

The past hadn't been erased or rewritten—it had been corrected, completed, made whole again.

As town librarian, Lucy couldn't have asked for a more fitting resolution. Books had provided both the mystery and its solution. Words, carefully examined, had revealed their hidden truths. And a librarian's attention to detail—to footnotes and marginalia, to the small things others might overlook—had ultimately brought justice for Clara Beth Jennings and for history itself.

Brentwood Falls would never be quite the same. But as Lucy looked around at her beloved town in the gathering twilight, she knew that the changes—however painful their catalysts had been—had ultimately strengthened rather than weakened their community.

The truth, as it always did in libraries, had found its way to the light.

JOIN THE MYSTERY CLUB

Love Cozy Mysteries? Get Full Series on Release Day!

No more waiting for the next book—binge the *entire* series the moment it launches! Bestselling mystery author **Maisy Marple** has teamed up with six talented authors to bring you **better books, faster!**

books 7 Authors, Full Series on Day One – No waiting for the next book!

wrapped gift Free Books & Exclusive Discounts – Just for subscribers!

fire All Books in Kindle Unlimited – Read for free with your membership!

If you love cozy mysteries, this is the newsletter you *can’t* miss! CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP! woman detectivesparkles

READ MORE

Love cozy mysteries? We've got plenty more for you!

Visit our Maisy Marple Publishing Amazon page, where you'll find so many delightful cozy mysteries from seven amazing authors! Whether you love small-town sleuths, culinary capers, bookish whodunits, or pet-loving detectives, there’s something for everyone.

books Discover your next favorite mystery today! CLICK HERE!